All I want to say is this:
My daughter was/is the same way. EVER since she started preschool at 4 years old... each Teacher, each Year, has said the same thing about my daughter...that she is SHY. They say it as though something is 'wrong' with her... and that she/we have to make her less shy and more participatory in class etc. The same drill.
My take on it: I see NOTHING wrong with my daughter. She is in fact... very wise and smart and funny and creative and bright and more aware of social situations than most kids or adults. And, she WILL stand up for herself and can debate like an Attorney and she will also stand up for other kids who are being picked on. WE are proud of her. But she is 'shy' in groups. Fine.
- Sure, we have "tried" to make her less shy... and we talk with her about it, and she has a lot of friends and hobbies and playdates and outings...but you know what? That is her personality. So be it.
I see nothing wrong with her... .and ALL the Teachers have told us that my daughter is a PERFECT student, PERFECTLY behaved and they wish all their students were like her....BUT she is shy. Each year we get that comment. It is irritating... I see is as a 'bias' against shy kids... I don't think, that kids "have to be" gregarious and social. 'Shyness" is NOT A "wrong" thing to be.
I was similar as a child... and I grew out of it... in time ever since I was in upper grades.
Now... you have to consider the "impact" that that has on your child... how do you think THEY feel... when EVERYONE is commenting on how "shy" they are as though it is a disease??? My daughter, gets SO tired of hearing that. But WE, her parents, do NOT bother with that anymore... in fact, I TELL the Teacher nicely and directly, that I see no problem with my daughter... and her "shyness" is all subjective... BECAUSE my daughter DOES participate or engages or volunteers for things... she is just NOT "loud" like the other kids or as 'in your face' or making trouble to other kids type of kid. So... to me, "shyness" is not a big deal.
And I do not know WHY Teachers always comment about 'shy' kids like it is such a bad thing.
Just my thoughts,
All the best,
Susan