J.S.
I love this question!!! I have found something that works soo wonderful for me, and feel many parents may like it too.
I am a love and logic mom, and I love the Love&Logic approach to allowance. They say "would you make your child work for pencils for school? for thier books? for the paper or supplies needed?" Most parents probably say no. "So why should we make our children EARN the money to learn Money Management?"
I Give my son 7 dollars a week, on saturday morning, with an invoice that says:
Amount: 7.00
Less Charges____________ For:
Total:______
Save 10% and Enjoy the Rest.
When its Gone, Its Gone.
We Love You!
The way I look at it, Kids cost money, Ice cream cones at the store, candy bars here and there, a little treat, movies, skating, swiming, toys between Birthdays and Christmas because they want it sooo bad!!!
I just Give my son the money I spend on him to manage.
BUT... There is a methood to my madness..
He gets assigned chores, we went trough and made and age appropriate list of things WE ALL DO to make our house hold function, I dont get paid to do my chores, he dont get paid to do his chores. BUT if he doesnt do his chores, He can pay someone else to do them, and I can do the same, say he wants to earn extra cash, "mom, I'll clean your bathroom for 10 dollars!!" I tell him, "No thanks, too much for me, I'll do it my self" He says "Well how will you pay me to do it then?" I tell him 2 dollars" He can take it or leave it, He's learning to negoiate, to think for him self, to work for something above and beyond what he already does, He's learning so much, then if He doesnt do his bathroom, and doesnt get someone else to do it, No problem, I'll do it, I dont mind, but I charge a lot more than maybe one of his friends.
When the money is already in his hands, its harder to give it up, so he does his chores so he can keep his money.
When he has to EARN the money, if he doesnt do his chores, he really dont care because he didnt have it in the first place and you cant miss what you never had. And he know's mom will pay for stuff still..
I am so amazed at how good my son is with money, He has been very careless with his "easy earned" money and got 65 dollars stolen, cheep lesson (expensive for him), now he bought a wallet, keeps his money in there and in his pocket at all times. He Never goes w/o knowing where his money is and how much he has, and when he wants something, He pays for it, I encourage him to want things, and to believe in him self enough to have what it takes to get it, and I have more money in my wallet too because with him buying all his stuff, (I am his mother so I do buy necessities and treat him once in a while) but I'm not over spending because I'm not paying attention to how much is going out of my own wallet, its 7 dollars a week, 28 dollars a month at the most, He's 12 and in 7th grade, It was less when he was younger, kids cost less when they're younger, but he has to save for his College, He chooses to have an additional savings in a safe we have at home for Rainy Days.
I'm truely amazed, you can learn more with the Love and Logic info, I cant remember which book I read it from but there website is http://www.loveandlogic.com
GL and Have Fun!!!
Sorry, I forgot one more thing: When my son didnt brush his teeth, and got cavities - Guess Who Paid for the Dentil Bill :) (giggle) that saved me a bunch of money too!!!