A.L.
I struggled to find a great one, too!!!
I have to 2nd the suggestion for Sephora's Tanning Bed in a Tube ($20). It has a bronzer and gradual tanning agent. Great product -- even has a slight shimmer! They make two products - one for body, one for face. Head to JCPenney and they'll give you a free sample of each! (It sold me!)
If you don't want a shimmer, and prefer a longer-lasting tan, Sephora/JCPenney also sells Faux Tan by Bare Essentials. It comes out green, so you see exactly where it goes! It has a gorgeous bronzer & leaves a tan that last 3-5 days (NO KIDDING!). It is a darker tan than Tanning Bed in a Tube, and I have to be pretty careful when I apply it because I know it's going to last.
Here are links so you can see the products: http://sephora.com/browse/product.jhtml?id=P182409&ca...
http://sephora.com/browse/product.jhtml?id=P99721&cat...
Hope this helps!