A.C.
I didn't use either. I used my regular lotion (St. Ives collagen & elastin) & put it on often. The girls at work helped a bunch-when I started absentmindedly scratching my belly, they'd slap my hand & pass me the lotion. It's really the motion, rather than what you use-massaging it in helps a bunch. I got 2 stretch marks (1/2" long coming out of my belly button) w/my first & just used my regular lotion. My 2nd baby, I didn't lotion & I've got what looks like a map on my belly now.