J.K.
Dear A.,
Are you not providing the pizza in order to keep the price down? I think it might be considered tacky. If you were having a party at your home, you would have stuff to eat other than cake, even if it wasn't a whole sit down meal. Also, (this is the case in the CEC closest to our home -- the one on Ogden in Naperville) the space is divided up at CEC into the general area and the party zone, and kids who are in the party zone have the CEC employees sing, serve the pizza and cake, dance w/ Chucky, etc. It sounds to me like you would be skipping out on this and trying to handle the tokens, etc., yourself. There will be no place for your group to sit all together if you aren't an organized "party" -- the tables that accomodate large groups are all reserved by CEC for parties and you will be left with a collection of small booths which will be awkward. Monkey Joe's is very popular for parties -- we havent' been there yet so I can't discuss the layout or anything. My impression is that Monkey Joe's is geared toward your age group. Pump it up in Lisle is popular, but a 4 year old might find it big and not really age appropriate. Big Bounce in Naperville or Airtastic in Aurora could be good choices. At Airtastic, I know you can bring your own cake and use their party room and I don't think you have to buy any of their food, and they have a good-sized part of the building that is for smaller kids. I'm sure you can find all these places if you google them. Good luck!