D.D.
Try making a few different finger sandwiches. For my son's second birthday party we made cheese, pb&j, BLT, roast beef, and open-faced cucumber finger sandwiches. I also made a big fruit salad and had fresh vegetables with dip. A simple cake, juice boxes, waters, and sodas and the day was perfect. If you want some recipes or planning tips, just send me a private note.
Have fun.