C.H.
My suggestion is to call around. Call at least 5 or 6 different companies. Premiums can vary widely for the same coverage.
I have had auto and homeowners insurance for about 35 years. I changed to Allstate and saved considerably. My son was recently a victim of road rage and was ran off of the road. His car was totaled. Allstate was right on it and it took 9 days to pay off the loan on his car that was totaled and send him the difference. I could not be happier with Allstate.
I had to fight with Progressive last summer for my mother in law whose pipe under her sink leaked and ruined her flooring and cabinets. It took 4 months of fighting everyday but they did finally settle. It was a real pain to fight for though. She had the policy 30 years and never had a claim. She is 78 and I think the company assumed that she would just give up --- but I didn't.
It is usual for 1 year pre paid homeowners insurance when purchasing a home. I used to be a mortgage loan officer and this is normal practice.
Remember that at closing, as long as you have the 1 year pre paid, you can always change companies after closing. It is just easier to find a company with premiums that you are comfortable with before closing.
Make sure that you have your homeowners premium included with your mortgage payment. It is so much easier that way.
Also, when comparing insurance premiums --- remember to compare the coverages with each companies. Sometimes it is worth paying a little more to get the extra coverage. You only have to insure the home for the amount of the loan. Most companies will want to insure you home for the replacement value but you just need to pay off the loan should something happen.
Hope this helps and congratulations on your new home.
chollows