Helping My Kids Adjust to Their Half-sister's Gender Change

Updated on May 13, 2008
L.S. asks from Wheaton, IL
3 answers

My 3 kids - girl (4), boy (3), and boy (almost 4 mos.) - have a 19-year-old half-sister from my husband's first marriage who I will call "Laura". Laura lives in NYC, and, except for 1-2 short visits a year, she historically has had little contact with the kids except occasionally by phone, either when their dad is in NYC visiting her, and/or when their dad is with them in IL and on the phone with her. Nevertheless, the kids are very aware of who she is - they have always proudly told people that they have a "big sister Laura".

Last week, Laura was in town from NYC visiting my husband (we are separated), and the two of them had a 6-hour visit with my 2 oldest kids. My kids had eagerly looked forward to the visit with daddy and their big sister. For the past year, however, Laura has begun living, looking, acting and dressing like a man, including adopting a man's name and getting a "buzz" haircut. I hadn't prepared my kids for any of this since my husband and I had agreed in advance that the only thing that he and Laura would tell our kids was that she wanted to be called by a new name. Unfortunately though, Laura apparently explained much more than that to them when their dad stepped away for a moment, including that she is their "sibling" and not their sister anymore, and that the next time she saw them, her voice will be much lower. My daughter, who is almost 5 and very verbal and precocious, came home shocked and confused by it all, while my 3-year-old son seemed relatively unfazed since I think he simply didn't understand any of it. Since then, my daughter has been "acting out" at home and at school and has started crying at times that never used to bother her, such as when I drop her off at ballet class and tell her that I'll be back later to pick her up.

Now that the cat is out of the bag, the question is what to do as far as helping my daughter - and eventually my son - cope with the loss of their "big sister" and all the other changes that go with the gender change, like calling Laura now by "his" new name and referring to Laura (or at least hearing adults, especially their dad, identifying Laura) as their "brother" and with words like "he", "him" and "his". I am most interested in hearing from anyone with clinical training in a situation such as this, or with insight based on their own experience in a similar situation (e.g., perhaps a family member "coming out" as gay). What should I say/do and not say/do?

In case any of this is relevant, I met Laura when she was 12 after dating her dad for several months, since we knew early on that we wanted to get married. From day one, she didn't want to meet me and resented my existence in her dad's life since it had basically been just the two of them until I came along. (Her mom is mentally ill, heavily medicated, and in-and-out of psychiatric wards.) Although she lived with her dad and me for the first year and a half of our marriage - first in NYC and then in Chicago - she moved back to NYC in 2003 to live with her mom when she turned 15 since she basically hated me and her father's new life (we had just had our first child). After she moved back to NYC, things continued to go from bad to worse in what little relationship I had with her, to the point where, for the past year, she and I have had no contact (her choice, not mine). She doesn't try to hide her hate for me, especially now that her father and I are separated. In fact, she sat outside in his car last week while he was picking up our oldest 2 kids and had no interest in coming into the house to see her new baby brother, who she has never met. Before arriving at the house, she expressed to my husband her fear and revulsion at the thought that I might come out and say "hi" to her - which I would have done if she weren't so averse to my doing so.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.R.

answers from Chicago on

L.,

your situation is so very unique... I don't know that I could give you advice from a point of view that has been 'there', but I think I can empathize with the best of 'em and when I first read your post I thought 'wow!' :) I've been mulling it over, and I think a) your step daughter has no interest in handling this appropriately for their age because she dislikes you, no matter what the cause of the animosity, it's there. and b) someday she will grow up a little... unfortunately you won't see the positive of this because you and her father are splitting up. I really believe that her presence in your kids life will most likely be minimal unless you and her father get back together. Sadly your kids will probably lose their 'big sister' :( So, I'm inclined to say be as general as possible but don't lie...

I would maybe say 'sometimes people are born girls on the outside, but inside they feel like boys and when they get older and feel sure that their outside doesn't match the inside, they decide to live how they feel. In Laura's case, she feels like a boy on the inside so she is changing her life so other people see her as a boy.

And then leave it at that. Our society is very unique... and we have to find ways to explain those situations that fall outside our kids 'norm' without building a prejudice to them.

I recall going to the Taste of Chicago once with my girls when they were younger (maybe about 7 and 9) and they saw a LOT of gay men, walking together and holding hands and even saw a couple making out while waiting to cross the street - of course they embarrassed us by blurting out 'MOM! those two boys are KISSING!' - after turning several shades of red, I explained simply that some boys like boys, and some boys like girls and both are ok.

Now my 6th grader has been exposed to bi-sexuality in her school. There is an 8th grade girl on her bus who has been making out with both boys AND girls in the back of the bus...

I personally don't subscribe to that lifestyle, but I don't want my kids to feel it's bad... if they choose that lifestyle I would support them and I wouldn't want them to feel like they couldn't come to me and share with me their choice to be gay. But, I also don't believe that a persons sexual orientation should define who they are. I mean... I don't walk around with shirts that define my fetishes... so, that being said, at their age especially, they don't understand the sex aspect between a man and a woman, let alone a man and a man, and a woman and a woman, so for now, leave it out :)

Good luck to you L.,

Happy belated Mother's day!

~J.~

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.L.

answers from Chicago on

You poor dear I feel badly for you it sounds like your doing everything right so try not to feel bad about yourself, I think she has had resentment towards you for a long time, she also may be depressed because of her mother. I would just inform her somehow that the kids don't understand what she is going through they are too little so they don't need any information until they are older. I also would feel alittle bad if she didn't want to see me but thats just more drama don't we have enough. Take care of you and the kids they come first A.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.G.

answers from Chicago on

It sounds like Laura needs some counseling or more parental guidance. Maybe you can suggest it to your husband? Why does he let her have control? (calling her "he" and letting her be so rude to you and your kids).

As far as your younger daughter, maybe she needs to be reasured that the other relationships in her life are stable and will not change? That you and her father love her, are there for her, and will stay the same.

This sounds like a frustrating and tough situation. I hope you get some good advice and I hope you can work things out. Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches