I would definitely send my son to a home like that and pay more. Like the previous posters said, you might be limiting yourself to those mothers with only one child (me) or those that have their older children in school, but since you would only need 4 kids, I don't think it would be much of a problem. I specifically chose a center for my 17-mo old now because I didn't want him in a home where the other kids weren't his age, but would have loved to have the option of a home that just had other infants/toddlers.