You've gotten some KILLER responses :) Yaaaay, love it when that happens.
We're in our 3rd year HS'ing and there are still days with doubts, days with my forehead making an impression against the drywall, days where I look at my friends who have 8 hours a day to pursue their own lives & I get jealous, days where I just plain and simple sweat the small stuff...
Here's a few things I've learn directly to your q's
1.a It scares me that I would solely be responsible to ensure that my kids got the best education.
- The short of it: You're only solely responsible if you want to be... and who determines "best"? Tackling the 2nd part first... what do you consider to be the best education? This is one of those q's I ask myself all the time. In away-school "best" is determined by either schoolboards & curriculum lobbyists (not alway a bad thing, but definitely remember... scope and sequence is a political animal that changes district to district and state to state... with the fedgov periodically also joining the other chefs in the kitchen), OR by private school boards, OR by boarding school boards. You will NOT find 2 schools, even in the same district who all go about "best" in the same way. As soon as you jump entities (districts, state, public, private, boarding) "best" is more varied than a pile of socks. One of the *great* things about HS'ing, and that gets me through some of the hard times, is that *I* get to determine best. LOL... I even get to determine our school motto: Mens Sana in Corpore Sano; a healthy mind in a healthy body. But that's us. The point being... no schoolboard gets to determine that my xyear old is too young to read a certain book, incapable of doing quantative math, doesn't get music or science or fieldtrips or sports... or "should" or "shouldn't" be able to do *anything*. My choice. Buck stops here. Which, yes, is also kind of the scary part... BUT...
Hahaha... I don't live in a vacuum. Yes I can reinvent the wheel if I so choose. Or I can research, borrow freely from existing philosophies and curricula, experiment... etc. I can quite easily get ahold of the scope and sequence from nearly any private school in the country, ditto any nationwide tests. I get to pour through curriculums, and test them out. AND I can farm out anything I durn well choose. Which brings us on to 1.b.
1.b Am I really capable of teaching my kids everything they need to know to thrive as adults?
Probably not. Fortunately we don't have to be. HS'ing doesn't mean living under a rock. We live in a society FILLED with people, classes, tutors, seminars, etc. You don't know a thing you want your children to learn, you have 3 options as a homeschooler: 1) learn it. 2) enroll them in a class and have someone else teach them. 3) wait for them to be old enough to teach themselves.
Although for elementary curriculum, DO realize that you're primarily teaching them how to read, write, simple math, question, & investigate. My suspicion is that you already know how to do those things. The other things they learn in school ( standing in line, taking turns, playing well with others you've already been teaching, I'm sure each and every single day). There's a great line from "the Bitter Homeschooler's Wishlist" http://www.secular-homeschooling.com/001/bitter_homeschoo...:
#12 If my kid's only six and you ask me with a straight face how I can possibly teach him what he'd learn in school, please understand that you're calling me an idiot. Don't act shocked if I decide to respond in kind.
Somthing I DO have to remind myself as an elementary HS'er... is that we WILL be covering this material again. So while I personally teach for mastery, I also know my 7 year old will be coming back to study ancient egypt again. Or physics. Or or or or. They're not going to learn everything in one shot. So for right now, it's foundation + EXCITEMENT. Love of learning. Self confidence. Curiosity. I can do that.
1.c Can I really run a home program?
Well that all depends. I know sahm/ds who run their HS. I know working m/ds who run their HS.... and everything in between. I also know people in both groups who attempt and don't like it. If you really want to; yes. Yes, you can. There will be challenges, no matter what. It's work, and it's not easy. But it's great fun. I often tell people that it's not the homeschooling that is hard... homeschooling is easy... it's the PARENTING that's hard.
2. I loved school! Am I going to be depriving my kids of a really good experience if I decide to keep them out of a public school?
6 of 1, half a dozen of another. In the first place, just because you homeschool, doesn't mean that you can't send them to away-school later. Secondly... what will your kids miss out on if they're away-schooled? The list changes for every family... but here are a FEW of the things my own kiddo would miss out on if he was away-schooled:
- Family time (not only with us, but he also gets one day a week with nana)
- Friends time (byproduct of HS'ing is having a LOT of time to form deep and meaningful relationships with others)
- Mentors (kiddo has sooooo many amazing people in his life, that again he just wouldn't have time for if we away schooled)
- Classes (he is in a ton outside activities and classes, and we'd have to drop all but 1 or 2 simply because there would be no time)
- Field trips (some months nada, most months 2-3)
- Learning everywhere (we did snowboard homeschool this winter taking our work up the slope M-F.... in the summer our work comes with us to the beach. We do school at the park, at coffee shops, in airplanes, in cars, at the dining table, on skates... we can and do, do school any and everywhere.
- Sleeping in (this is HUGE, as anyone who has dealt with tired cranky kids will attest. For a month this fall kiddo was in a growth spurt and slept in until 930-10am.
- The classic "school in jammies"
- Playtime
- Physical Exercise (right now we spend 6-8 hours a day doing active things, and about 4 on school, that wouldn't just get reversed... because in away school there's also homework and family time to be squeezed in. So it's not curling up with a movie after a day spent swimming/skiing/hiking/whatever we were up to, but curling up with a movie after sitting down for 7 hours of school and 2 of homework??? Ummmmm... yeah.))
- Ohhhhh the list goes on.