Please listen to those of us that have hypothyroidism and don't mess around when it comes to this disease! The thyroid gland is part of an intricate balance of hormones and you can really throw your whole body and emotions out of whack including the rest of your endocrine system.
I too cannot stand taking pills, but I was diagnosed at 20 yo after calling my mom to report that I thought I was having a nervous breakdown. I was exhausted, depressed, cold, having anxiety attacks and becoming somewhat agorophobic. I have been on synthetic thyroid for almost 20 years and I have been able to successfully switch to generics. Generic synthroid does not work as well for some people, so you may want to start out on brand name. Now that I am VERY familiar with the symptoms of low thyroid levels, I am going to try switching to the natural porcine form of thyroid hormone called Armour because some patients report higher energy and better success with weight loss...although this too is a prescription in pill form.
I think it is a great idea to supplement taking your thyroid medication with healthier eating habits, exercise, and supplementation of iodine, cortisol, selenium and other adrenal support products. However, first you must get your body regulated and learn more about the symptoms as well as tune into how your body feels when levels are normal vs. low. I personally have never heard of anyone "recovering" from hypothyroidism, especially if it is Hashimoto's, which is the autoimmune form of the disease.
Also, if you want to have more children, you need to keep your thyroid in balance or you could risk miscarriage and possibly other issues. Additionally, if you do become pregnant, your OB or regular Dr. should be checking your thyroid levels as you gain weight. Sometimes during or after pregnancy with all the hormonal changes you can swing the other way. My sister who was diagnosed as Hashimoto's hypothyroid close to 20 years ago recently stopped breastfeeding her daughter and has gone hyperthyroid, but it will probably normalize back to hypo once her hormones balance out.
Please be careful, be informed and find a good doctor to help guide you. Taking the thyroid meds really is no big deal aside from remembering every day and waiting 30 minutes after to eat or take other vitamins/supplements. Take care and feel free to email me directly if you want.
--C.