My 3-Year-old Scratches, Kicks, Hits, Spits, and Screams.

Updated on March 13, 2011
A. asks from Junction City, OR
12 answers

In the last few months, my son has started doing the above-named behaviors when he gets told to not do something. We have a naughty chair that he is put in when he behaves like this,and he will eventually say that he is sorry; however, he turns right around and does it the next time. We have tried spanking and that does not phase him one bit. He is very strong willed and smart. I do have him involved in a preschool a couple of times a week as an outlet. I had a difficult time trying to find anything like this on the internet. Any help would be appreciated. A.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Things are going much better. I am more calm and just take him and put him in his chair. He still continues to do the behavior for a while in the chair, but I just keep telling him that he is getting more time for each thing that he does. He will stay in the chair, THANK GOD! After about 10 minutes, he seems to realize that he is not getting to me and starts saying that he wants to talk. I try to hold off though for a little longer, and then I will go in and talk to him about his behavior. He apologizes and then he will hug and kiss me. The key I think is with me and how I react to him. TY for all of your responses.

Featured Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.C.

answers from Portland on

My son outgrew major fits very early at 2. He has small ones still at 8. BUT my 5yo is very stubborn and still has days like this (thankfully they are getting less and less), but we just have to be consistent. No matter what she is in trouble and she will not get out of time out until she has calmed down and apologized if need be. We've also had to be firm with gramma since gramma has the kids every few weekends. Gramma feels bad and wants to give in to the temper tantums. All caregivers have to be consistent or she will know where the "holes" are.

Hang in there!

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.G.

answers from Portland on

Yes consistency is key. There also may come a point where if it still doesnt help you may want to talk to his doctor. There can be allergies and other conditions that can affect a childs behaviour and make them overly aggressive. Over stimulation and understimulation can be major culprits too. I have to agree with a few of the others that spanking wont help. Spanking to make them stop being aggressive. its a rather viscious cycle isnt it. it just seems to come out as who can be the biggest bully, the kid or the parent.

But sometimes it really is just the lovely phase all preschoolers go through. They are learning what they can and cant get away with. and what ways people will react to them.

Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.S.

answers from Seattle on

I would give my son (now almost four) ONE swat on the rear end ANY time and each and EVERY time he was physically aggressive toward a person or a pet and would tell him that (the specific behavior) was not allowed. (You say you "tried spanking," so I'm guessing that you've stopped and/or you were not consistent.) I gave my son a swat every single time he was physically aggressive, and it didn't matter where we were or what we were doing or whether or not he immediately apologized after he did something. It also didn't matter if he gave a gentle swipe or a hard hit. The consequence was exactly the same. I became the queen of consistency. It was REALLY hard, and after one day he earned six separate swats I went into the bathroom and cried because I was positive it wasn't going to work and I was hitting my son for no benefit.) But I stuck with it. It felt like FOREVER but it really didn't take long at all for him to stop trying to hurt people. Once he really understood that the consequence for trying to hurt someone was a swat on the bottom, he stopped choosing the behavior. For spitting and screaming, I send him to his room and tell him that the behavior is unacceptable and not something I want to see. He's allowed to come out as soon as he's composed himself. (This usually only takes a couple of minutes.) If he throws a toy in anger, that toy goes into "toy time-out." He can earn it back by doing something especially helpful (clearing the dinner table).

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from Anchorage on

He sounds a lot like our son before we found the Fiengold Program. Check it out online! It has made our son much more calm and he has self control now! YEAH!! There are some food addatives and naturally occuring chemicals that his body just can't process and result in irrational behavior and no self control. It has been a life saver!!! Check it out, I doubted it when my sister came across it online but it has made a wonderful change in our home!!
Best of Luck~
K.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.B.

answers from Portland on

Hi A., I have six kids, my youngest is 3. I have gone through this stage with all my kids. You have to be consistant each and everytime. I hate to say they will be this way until they can communicate very well. Just remember not to give in. They will learn they behaive one way to get something they want, the behavivor will go on and on and on. Make sure you have everyone helps you in the same way. It can confuse them. On how ro punish them, You choose what makes you comfortable. Most faycare/preschools use time out. I use both, I start with time out then a swat on the bum, and then tag dads it.
Just remember how sweet they are when they have every button pushed.
Good luck

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

V.D.

answers from Seattle on

i apologize that i don't have any advice, but my son is almost 3 and going through the same thing, so times for no identifiable reason. please, let me know if you get any good advice.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.C.

answers from Seattle on

It sounds like your son has moved emotionally, and emotions are overwhelming him. My daughter did the same, and my just turned 3-year-old is growing into this now. He's feeling tremendous emotions, far stronger than he did a year ago, but he doesn't know how to express himself in an acceptable way, so the emotions take over his body and he responds violently.

I would make sure to talk to him about what he's feeling, even if he can't express it in words. If you express it, and help him find ways to show his feelings without going overboard, you'll help him learn to express them in a productive way. When my son acts up, I say, "You are frustrated!" and often he repeats what I say and calms himself down. He just has more emotion than he knows what to do with, and he has to learn how to show it and deal with it in a constructive way.

Good luck! I know exactly what you're going through!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.G.

answers from Seattle on

I think you are doing great! The only thing I suggest besides staying with it is to take a prized possession away if the time out hasn't helped. (So time out + take away toy = step 2) and keep doing that. When he does something really nice or helpful, he may take one of his toys out that he has lost. We had to do this for a short while with my 4 year old and didn't have to very long before he got the picute. Hope it helps!

K.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.W.

answers from Spokane on

my son went through the same stage and we didi it all, when he spit we spanked him and it worked sometimes, ehn he hit or scratched i would totally wlk away from him and not talk to him until he was ready to be nice, I would tell him once I was not going to talk to him until he was ready to be cool. I think I even washed his mouth out with soap for spitting and that worked great, goo old dawn the same thing my parents did.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.K.

answers from Portland on

well im sorry to hear that.
have you turned the tables and looked at your life and your husbands. most kids who act out are realy trieing to tell you something but they cant verbilize it.pay attention to him how his attitude is at every decision that is made for him or places you go people hes around or even the mention of someones name. his attitude,body language,facial expressions will tell you everything you need to know.is there tention in the house, is there inconsistincy with daily routines, punishment,remember at this age they cant communicate using words and they pick up on any yelling,silence,bad attitudes,tone of voice,or being ignored(im to busy to play with you right now),not enough enthousazim and excitement when he does something you ask or anything he does that is positive.my advice love,punish,be consistant,lots of hugs, praise,routine,structure,rules and quality play time with all 3 of you.this kid is defenitly sensing some thing different or bad.i hate to say it but what about anybody or kids touching him.I pray thats not it.Im sorry its not normal to do all of those things to that extent.relax and take deep breaths he will react to your anger etc.does he have rewards,for chores like a to do list with stars the more stars he accumulates the more superises he gets. my son loves his reward calander.keeping all the chores the same every week now he does things and runs dragging me and bugging me for the star sticker (that i keep hidden so he cant cheat)to put a star on his calander every 5 stars we go shopping me and him only and picks out a small toy and once a week i come home with a superize something small or cheap he goes crazy knowing i was thinking about him and i was paying attention to him and everything he was doing he loves responsibilty.Remember kids learn faster by seeing and watching you guys.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.P.

answers from Portland on

Your son is acting out in a manner that is normal at this age. That's not to say that you should let him act this way but perhaps it will help you feel less anxious about it. He has strong feelings and he doesn't know how to express them.

One way to help him is (when he's not acting out) to describe your own feeling at the moment (frustration, anger, sadness, happiness) and talk about how you feel and what you are going to do about it. For example; you drop something in the kitchen for the umpteenth time and you say to him "I am so frustrated that everything seems to fall out of my hands. I'm going to stamp my feet a couple of times." Then, "whew! I feel better now."

Another important thing is to notice when he has these meltdowns and what may have caused them. Try to prevent him from becoming over tired or hungry or from too much stimilation. Be consistent with naps, meal and snack times, and if you take him shopping do it when he's rested and fed.

And try to use the word "no" as little as possible. No is a red flag even to adults. Instead try "you can play with this toy. I have to put this one up for now." Or if he wants to do something say, we can do that later and if you know when say when, now we must do this. Also give choices whenever possible. Say he wants to push all the buttons on the TV. Hand him a toy he likes and if that doesn't work pick up another one and tell him he has a choice between this one and this one, all the while walking him away from the TV.

And remember 3 yo have little to none long term memory. You are going to be repeating yourself over and over for awhile. It's the repetition in a calm manner that teaches them. When one gets angry the child focuses on the anger and misses the message you're trying to relay.

Time outs work well for some kids but not at all for others. I give my 6 yo and 3 yo grandchildren time outs by telling them to go to their room until they can behave better. I say when you stop crying or stop hitting or ???? you can come back out. Sometimes I say I don't want to hear you yelling or ??? I emphasize what behaviour I want changed and how I want them to behave. I never tell them they are bad in any form. They are misbehaving and it's the behavior I want to change.

With my granddaughter I sometimes anticipate misbehavior by noticing that she is tired and hungry. Then I change our activity. If we're out we go home or stop to get something to eat. At home we do something quiet. At my house she usually needs me to stay with her and we read or watch a video. At her house she usually goes to her room and plays or watches TV. Sometimes she wants to be rocked or even just held. I think that she's learned these ways of calming herself because that is the way I calm myself and have done those things with her.

When my granddaughter was 2 and 3 she would throw lying on the floor kick and scream temper tantrums freqently, sometimes everyday and not necessarily because she wanted something I wouldn't allow. I'd stay in the room with her, out of her reach, and when she calmed down she would crawl over and sit on my lap. I think, as one of the mother's said, that kids this age just do not know how to handle strong feelings. The feelings take over. And it's our job as adult caretakers to show them how to recognize those feelings and then how to manage them. It is not easy!

I found an easy to understand site for the Feingold Program and can see how it could be helpful. Here's the address: http://www.feingold.org/home.html

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.B.

answers from Knoxville on

My Daughter turned 3 in January.. She does the EXACT same thing. She is very smart but extremely head strong. If we tell her to do something or try to make her stop doing something she always reacts with the yelling, hitting,scratching, spitting, ect. We have tried time out, spanking, anything and everything! Its so hard to not get frustrated when you cant make your child stop their behavior like that.. Wish i had an answer to make her stop and help calm my nerves!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches