A.P.
For my first, I went with Marla Scott at St. Clare's. I had an awful experience, and then realized I could not go back to the hospital.For my second, I had a home birth. What a difference! I would do it again in a heartbeat. My midwife was Jessica Lawlor--contact me if you want more info. She is so knowledgeable, professional, caring, and helpful during pregnancy, even after the birth. Her back-up doctor is at Morristown, so that's where you go if you end up needing to transfer (but she has an extremely low transfer rate as you are pre-screened/given clearance for a home birth).
One more thing, you can find out c-section rates at hospitals, as well as epidural, episiotomy rates, etc. In hindsight, I believe I was treated the way I was at the hospital because they are just used to dealing with women who get the epidural. So they weren't too helpful or interested in letting me labor on my own, in my own position, and they were quick to cut me and use forceps, and I hadn't even had an epidural! So in my opinion, those rates will be helpful in making a decision as to where to birth your baby.
http://www.icanofnj.com/hospitalcsectionrates.htm
Good luck whatever you decide.