Hi, L.. I am just about to potty train my third child. The first two were so easy - I just hope this one will be, too! I read the book about potty training in a day and just felt like it was too extreme for me. I know a lot of people like it, but it didn't really seem to fit for me. However, my first two kids were essentially potty-trained in one day. I'll tell you how...
First of all, he is ready if:
1. He can express verbally the concept of "poop" or "pee."
2. He can pull his own pants up or down.
3. He occasionally tells you if he needs a diaper change - at least when its poopy.
So, here's my trick. I decided to make a chart for my kids - but it was not just any chart. I made it big (out of poster board) and made it look a bit like a Candyland board game where you travel along a path from start to finish. Every time my child went to the bathroom and their underwear was still dry, they got to put a sticker in one of the squares along the path. Every few squares, there was a bigger picture of a reward. For instance, one was a picture of McDonald's. When my child progressed to that square, we hopped into the car and went to McDonald's - immediately.
At first, there were only a couple of squares until a reward space, then there were progressively a few more squares to each new reward. So, they had to stay dry a little bit longer each time. And the rewards got bigger and bigger. At first, it was something small, like a candy. Then a small toy (like a Matchbox car), then an ice cream cone, a trip to the park, McDonald's, swimming as a family, etc. The last prize was something each of my kids really wanted. For my daughter it was a rocking horse. For my son, it was a play castle.
The best part was the pictures. My kid could count with me to see how much further to each prize and the picture was a great reminder that they really did want what was coming! It is very important that the reward be immediate, so I made sure my schedule was clear for a few days so that I could be ready.
If my child went on the potty, but they had dripped a bit in their underwear, I still let them put a star on the board - just in the same square they had already put on in. They didn't progress unless they were dry between trips. I did this because I didn't really want to reward just sitting on the potty, I wanted to reward the fact that they were DRY.
I asked several times during the day if they were dry and reminded them to use the potty as soon as they needed to go, but I never forced them to use the potty at any regular times.
The miracle is, they put on their new underpants (no pull-ups because they're too much like diapers) and they never had an accident. Even at night, I thought for sure they would wet the bed, but neither of them did.
When my child reached the last square (the big reward), we all gathered around as a family and cheered as he put the sticker on. I will never forget the proud look on his face.
Hope this helps. Good luck.
P.S. We started out potty-training our boy sitting down for both pee and poop. After he was confident in making it to the bathroom (and tall enough), then we focused on standing up. Dad taught him to lift the seat, aim, and then put the seat back down. I am really grateful for that!!!