G.G.
Ok, first apologies because I didn't read all the other replies, so this may be duplicated. I found someone on Etsy.com who makes ceramic holiday items with names carved in them. Example, a ceramic pumpkin with the couples names carved where the mouth would be.
http://www.etsy.com/listing/33168619/personalized-ceramic.... She has something for all the major holidays and I always get asked "how did you think of that? Where did you get it?" at showers.
I received (and LOVED) everything to decorate a christmas tree-lights, ornaments, tree skirt, star, tree stand, etc. Saved us a ton of money and we thought fondly of the family that bought it each holiday season.
One of my bridesmaids got me a picnic basket, filled it with tons of goodies and a gift card for a local deli & Ravinia lawn seats. Loved that!
Whatever you decide-have fun with it and it'll show. :)