Hi H.!
How exciting! My son's 1st b-day was last August, and I can't believe how much time has flown by already--he's already 19 months now!!
You are definitely right about your little girl not remembering her 1st b-day party. She's definitely not going to care about what kind of decorations she has or what type of cake she has. But as for everyone else having such huge expectations...don't you worry about them!!! YOU are the one who has to deal with cleaning your house (if you have the party there), and the expense of the food, decorations, cake, etc, so whatever you want to do for a celebration is completely up to you (and your wallet!)
What I did for my son was this: I went to a discount party store and got the cute little plates with matching napkins, cups, etc, and other matching decorations. I also ordered a very large cake from Kroger (the theme was Madigasar), and I got one very small cake just for my son to dig his own hands into. If you want to do something similar, I would recommend the Kroger cakes to anyone,as it tasted really good, were very decently priced, and they did a wonderful job decorating else having such huge expectations...don't you worry about them!!! YOU are the one who has to deal with cleaning your house (if you have the party there), and the expense of the food, decorations, cake, etc, so whatever you want to do for a celebration is completely up to you (and your wallet!)
What I did for my son was this: I went to a discount party store and got the cute little plates with matching napkins, cups, etc, and other matching decorations. I also ordered a very large cake from Kroger (the theme was Madigasar), and I got one very small cake just for my son to dig his own hands into. If you want to do something similar, I would recommend the Kroger cakes to anyone,as it tasted really good and they did a wonderful job decorating it. But if you want to save money and bake your own cake (or even have a friend or family member do it for you), then do that! Oh and trust me: not a single person today could tell you what was on those paper plates I bought or the kind of decorations I had, so if you'd rather save money and buy plain old white paper plates and the fewest decorations imaginable (like just a few balloons), nobody is going to care!
We also ordered pizza and breadsticks and salad for dinner for everyone as well. Originally, to save money, I was NOT going to serve dinner and have the party around 1pm (and just word the invitations as saying "cake and ice cream will be served.") But I ended up changing the time of the party to 4:00 because I was inviting a ton of friends with kids (ages 4 and under) and most of them took naps earlier in the afternoon. So I figured I'd have to provide some sort of dinner if the party would be going on that late! If you decide to have your party during lunch or dinner, you can always ask people to bring a dish. You don't even have to ask all of your guests, just a few close friends/relatives if you want.
Oh, and speaking of guests...do not feel you have to invite everybody and their brother. Depending on where you have the party (space availability) and how much you want to spend, only invite those you truly want there and do not worry about hurting people's feelings.
May is such a nice time of year--if you don't want the party at your house, consider having it at a local playground (one that has a pavilion in case it ends up raining.) That would save you so much time from having to clean the house, I'm thinking about doing that for my son's 2nd b-day! And then there are always places like Chuck E Cheese's or Little Caesar's Playland (I have heard Little Caesar's in Madison Heights is cheaper than Chuck E Cheese.) Oh, and the zoo! That always seemed like a really cool place to have a b-day party! I know they do have them there!
If you're going to have any other kids at the party, you might wanna give them goody bags. Some people give them to kids on their way home, but I gave them to the kids right away so they could entertain themselves. I just got everything at the discount party store and the dollar store. Depending on the age of the child, you can give things like little bouncy balls, stickers, pencils and notepads, individual snacks (like Teddy Grahams or Animal Crakers, etc), and just stuff like that. I actually had 2 infants at my son's party, so I gave them things like jars of baby food (fruit), fruit puffs, and sippy cups. But again, don't feel you have to provide goody bags, it's just something to think about.
I have a friend who never does cakes for her son's parties...while he did get his own little cake for his 1st b-day, everyone else got (and continues to get) individual cupcakes.
My son ate his cake in his high chair, but someone told me for her own daughter's 1st b-day, she put her daughter in a small baby pool right inside the living room (with no water in it). She then put the baby in the pool with the cake and let her really go to town!! No matter what, be prepared to throw your daughter in the tub right after and have a change of clothes handy. It may not be necessary, but it most likely will be!
After all this rambling on, I hope I was able to give you at least one idea that is helpful!! One thing is for sure...you are going to be sooo proud of your baby girl on her birthday!! And THAT is something she will appreciate more than the cake, decorations, and presents she gets! Good luck!