Hi, I live in Oak Lawn, and I gave $5.00 an hour for one child, and $6.00 an hour for my two children. I know some places further South pay so much more. One person told me $15.00-$20.00 an hour....I was like holy cow. For one thing, that is CASH, and for another thing, I think I would love to quit work and work for that person! ha! Heck, half the time the babysitter is playing with them, and the other half they are sleeping (we usually need them in the evenings). So I think that is more than fair myself. They must think so too, because they come back! (Note, I pay the same amount for the person who comes to my house twice a week to watch them during the day as well). I have a 50-year old friend for the day, and usually the daughter to my friend, who is 30 years old watches them at night when we go on date nights. It is a hard economy out there, and when you factor the babysitting $, plus the evening you had planned, it could be tough!
Again, especially for a college student, $5.00 to $6.00 I think is more than fair.
Please note, I have one person who always cleans up after themselves, and one who doesn't. Funny how that works. I know when I used to babysit a million moons ago, my Mom always told me I better leave it like it was (at least). I usually did more when the kids were sleeping, and I did get paid extra alot because of it!
Good luck!