S.E.
K.,
I am a breastfeeding mom too and had the same trouble with my oldest daughter. She eventually took the two-toned gerber ones that say "infant pacifier." It is funny becuase they are huge and a newborn would never be able to put this in his/her mouth! I think the thing she liked was that the base was round and it covered her whole mouth like a breast. a note of caution, however, is that she will be three next month and has only recently given it up (with much cajoling and difficulty). In retrospect, I wish I had never found the "good binkies" as she would later call them! By the way, my little one is a thumbsucker, so who knows how I'll get that away from her. Good luck finding whatever it is that's right for you!