A.S.
I'm a Kid's Closet owner as well (Gardner, KS) and I would strongly encourage you to stick with consignment sales.
I have a 10 year old, an 8 year old and a 10 month old. I have been consigning for 8 years and I would second what everyone else has said: Infant clothes are the toughest to sell. There are just always so many of them and usually they are in really good shape. I know at my sale it is not uncommon to see the EXACT same outfit being sold by 2 or 3 consignors, and the cheapest is always the one that sells. Making the items available at 1/2 price on the last day makes a big difference too. I agree with Lori A - Shoppers on the last day are looking for a deal. I've rang up more people than I can count who realize that something in the pile isn't 1/2 price so they have it pulled out. Never mind that it is still a good deal - on that last day they want the discount.
Consignment stores (Once Upon a Child, Children's Orchid) are only going to take a portion of what you bring in and they usually pay LESS than $1 a piece. Garage sales bring in even less. As you little one grows I think you'll find that you can make the most back at consignment sales.
Kid's Closet is great for many reasons! The rewards program is nice, and we pay back the maximum percentage whether or not you work the sale. Most importantly though is the exposure our consignors get. We have many, many sales throughout the KC area and many of our consignors take thier items from one sale to the next. So what doesn't sell at the first sale, goes to the second, then the third...so on and so forth. (There are 7 Kid's Closet sales in the Metro area.)
It makes the time you spend tagging more worthwhile, because you have more opportunities to sell (without paying any additonal fees).
There is also a lot o truth to Jill's comments. I have held sales and attended sales where the girls infant clothing sold really, really well, while the boys did not, or 12-18m didn't sell so well and 2-4T did. It really depends on so many factors.
Best of luck to you with whatever you decide. If you'd like more information about Kid's Closet check out our website: www.kidscloset.biz
A.