My daughter had the same issue....at Cheektowga Central they now give updated progress report weekly....but prior to being able to keep up that often...I saw the same thing. She was a mini me....aced the tests, but did NO HOMEWORK.
But, test grades were 100, 99, 100, 96, 98, 99, 100...etc, etc
Grounding did nothing, taking away the electronics....she would sit and read a book swearing she had no homework. I made her drop band, pulled her out of gymnastics....Now I am worried about her becoming a lazy child.
I discussed it with teachers and we were all at a wits end. She didn't even try to make up excuses. They said she looked them in the face and said she didn't do it, as though there was no consequence. Unfortunately, middle schools give homework a high percentage in the final grade. 8th grade you can still pass with a zero in homework (thank god!!) and high school you can also... she better not plan on a good college admission with bad grades. We even discussed future plans, goals, the difference in wiping tables at Burger King and having a college education....Drove through the deepest ghetto to see what happens in low income communities. She is not hanging out with the wrong crowd, she see's no friends after school, its not even a possibility that it is drugs or alcohol experimentation.
So one day I went in to her room after the mid year report card was bad. I took a hand full of hefty bags into her room and cleared the shelves of everything!!! The look on her face to walk into a totally empty room....bare sheves, empty walls....as though she was robbed. I resorted to kidnapping all her precious things. Including every fuzzy stuffed animal, every collector item, earned trophies, cd's, video games, trinket gifts from friends and loved ones, memorable photos, even the most prized designer clothing. She had bare minimal items. Bedding and a few changes of clothes.
I left a ransom note stuck to the shelf with a list of demands, what grades she required in each class to hit an 85 or better for the final average.....no more yelling, no more bribing with rewards that she didn't care about. What bothered her the most? the threat on the ransom note that I will ebay items one at a time if I don't immediately see effort towards meeting the demands. Her fuzzy stuffed animals she had feelings for were to be donated personally by her to the volunteer ambulances and mercy flight to be given to pediatric patients. If the demands are not met in one semester? They would be all ebayed and the money put in a fund to pay for the community college she would resort to later in life since she is blowing her chances for any scholorships with her academic abilities being wasted. If the 5 week report showed her meeting her goals, I would start to release hostages. After she read the note, I explained that she had responsibilities that she was neglecting...she was not doing her job in life as a student. So, just like someone who refuses to participate in society and work? She was losing everything. I emailed and explained this drastic approach to all of her teachers. They all agreed to email me weekly with discrepancies.
She made immediate improvement....this forced her to use an agenda and keep track of assignments. After learning that personal organization helped her stay ahead, it motivated her to start the following year off organized and not fall apart knowing it is easier to stay organized than to try to fix a mess later.
If I could do it again, I'd only change the ransom note. I would explain it as ... she now has bad credit for not doing her job, and the repo man (repo mom) took everything away....she may purchase items back with good grades and good progress reports one at a time.
He is obviously smart enough to pull off good test scores without the monotonous practice of homework...he will understand the lesson you are teaching.
shhhh...now the perk for me??? She took back all of her prized possessions. But, many of the items that I begged to garage sale or throw away for the 3 previous years (junk collected over years), she finally chose to let go of leaving her bedroom neater and more organaized.