Gas Vs. Propane

Updated on March 17, 2014
E.B. asks from Sour Lake, TX
5 answers

We are building and unable to have natural gas and have opted for a propane tank vs. electric on a few items. One of those items is a stove which will be converted to deal with the propane. My concern is that it would make cooking on a gas grill more like cooking on a camp stove. Is there any difference in the 2 regarding cooking?? Anyone know?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.B.

answers from Oklahoma City on

There's no difference. When the valves are put in they are meant for natural gas. Propane has a different....texture?...weight?....substance?....I don't know what it is but the valve isn't the right size for the propane to come through at the right speed.

SO the different adjustment allows it to come through at the comparable rate as natural gas. It's not bad, when the tank is getting low you'll notice a very stinky smell. They add this to the tank so you can smell when it's getting low and notice. Then they'll need to come out and top you off.

My hints and hopefully helpful comments:
****************************************
We ran out of propane 3 times this winter. My father in law has a larger house and keeps his thermostat set nearly 10 degrees warmer than ours. He hasn't ran out even once. Our house is almost all electric too. Only the heater and stove/oven are gas. Nothing else. We should not be running out of propane at all.

If you're using too much propane find out why! Have your plumber come out and disconnect the propane tank then run a pressure test to make sure you don't have a leak in the lines the plumber installed.

If his pressure test is okay then call the propane company and insist they come out and do testing on their tank and connections.

They'll blame each other. "their lines are leaking not mine" "Not my issue, our pressure test shows our lines are good!"....blah blah blah.

If it can't be figured out then you might have to have the propane company come out and get their tank. Have another one put in. If the same thing happens with a different company it has to be an issue with the plumber's lines.
*******************************
Propane is sky high right now.

It cost us almost $2000 to fill our tank recently. We can't afford that. It's already down by 50% too.

If you watch your tank and propane prices fill it as much as you can when the prices are down low. Very low. Then when it gets cold you'll already have propane on hand.
*********************
My father in law got a whole house propane powered generator installed a few years ago after a huge ice storm hit OKC. It switches on every Tuesday at noon to cycle and do a self diagnosis. If the power goes out it automatically switches on until the power comes back on. He can successfully have power a week or so depending on what he's running and how full the tank is. We all go there when the power is out. We don't run the TV's and excess stuff a lot during these times. We want the propane to last as long as possible.
*********************************************

If you can, do electric hot water or on demand hot water that's gas. It is so nice to have good hot water that lasts a long time but doesn't use the propane.

Our electric dryer is awesome, I don't think I'll ever go back to gas. I grew up with a gas dryer and always demanded gas dryers as an adult. When my father in law bought me a new huge electric Samsung dryer I was annoyed. BUT when a load of jeans was dry before my washer was even done with the next load I was sold. I'll always use electric dryer's now.

I save propane too.
***********************************************
By having the propane leak/issue we've spent over $2500 on propane since November. The tank we got when we moved in lasted all last winter, summer, and fall....now we've used 3 tanks in 3 months. That's an obvious issue. Don't let them walk over you. Make them find leaks and reimburse you.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.W.

answers from Amarillo on

No, it is set up correctly you will never notice the difference. I grew up with a stove that was propane as my parents did not want to pay for the natural gas connection (1950s).

the other S.

1 mom found this helpful

J.P.

answers from Lakeland on

Cooking on a propane stove is the same as a natural gas stove (there is a very small valve that gets changed between the two stoves because the different densities of the gas) . They (propane or natural gas stoves) cook more evenly then an electric and if you should lose power for any reason you can still cook.

1 mom found this helpful

D.B.

answers from Boston on

I've only used propane on a stove in an RV, but the cooking is exactly the same as with a gas stove. When you say "cooking on a gas grill would be more like cooking on a camp stove," do you mean an indoor grill that's part of the stove? Or are you talking about an outdoor grill? All outdoor gas girls have their own propane tanks, right? So I don't know why that would change.

I'd look at the costs though - energy costs seem to fluctuate.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

O.O.

answers from Los Angeles on

I would opt for an electric stove indoors.
But an outdoor grill? We have a grill that uses propane--it's fine.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions