A.K.
I was homeschooled my entire childhood. A couple of Summers I went to the local public school "for fun". Most of my friends were homeschooled, some of my relatives were, all of my siblings were, and I've stayed in contact with many, many homeschooled kids as we've grown up.
My first question would be if you have a teaching degree. No child should be educated by an uneducated person. Homeschooling moms like to say that they can "learn along with their kids" but that is wrong wrong wrong. You should have a college degree if you're going to take on the responsibility of educating your children on every topic they need to know - Arithmetic, Writing, History, Science, Social Studies....etc. I know that is not the law in many places, but it should be. Too many women who didn't even finish high school or attend college themselves are teaching their children, and doing a shoddy job of it.
Secondly, WHY do you want to homeschool your children? Is it because your religious beliefs have you fearing science, and you fear your children being exposed to things like evolution, dinosaurs, proof of things you don't personally agree with? That is not a good reason to homeschool. If your children choose to follow the same religious path as you, that should be their choice - not one made for them because they've never been exposed to anything else.
Homeschool children very easily slip through the cracks in our system. I can't even tell you how many I knew who were abused at home, needed psychiatric help, had emotional issues or physical disabilities - and didn't get the help they could have received because no one but their close circle of trusted allies knew about these things. Homeschoolers don't turn in other homeschoolers, even when they see wrong being done. If your children are in a school setting, someone would notice if there was something bad going on or if they needed help. A good parent likes to think they would catch all of that, but even the best parents can mess up, not wanting to admit their child may need help.
What you said is a very honest assessment of the reason many people homeschool in the first place. They want to shelter their kids from the world and not let them be exposed to all those dangerous evil things that they believe are 'out there' waiting to get them. Personally, I was hammered into with the belief that public schools are terrible places where they do awful things to you - to this day I can't walk into one without feeling scared and queasy.
Public (or private) school offers many opportunities. Yes, bad things can happen at them, but bad things can happen anywhere. The key is to be involved with your childs education and to pick the best school possible for them to attend.
I don't advocate homeschooling for anyone. My education was shoddy (do you know how easy it is for a homeschool mom to have a lazy day/week/month/yeah and decide that your math lesson consists of paying for groceries at the store? Very easy), my social skills are laughable, and getting into college has been the biggest nightmare in the world. Even just a community college, where I don't have to prove any smarts to be accepted. It's extremely difficult to get in because every state has different rules about what homeschoolers are required to keep as records, what homeschoolers need to be taught (many of them aren't even tested annually to ensure that they are keeping up with their peers), and what paperwork you need to fill out to prove that you had any education at all. I don't get recognized as a high school graduate - I get recognized as a homeschool student who grew up and turned 18. My friends who have 'diplomas' had them made at home by their parents. Not easily accepted, either.
Think long and hard, please, before deciding to go down that route. Ask if you trust yourself to do as good a job as someone who has a 4 or 6 or 8 year college degree, and who can be held accountable when your child isn't learning. Figure out how you're going to get your children socialized - a couple playgroups a week is not sufficient for children past the age of 9 or 10. If you still think you can do it, then educate yourself on the laws in your state. I have run into homeschoolers here in my current state who don't even know the laws on the books - they just do what they want and get indignant if you tell them they are breaking the rules. Because homeschoolers, for some reason, are above the rules.
And finally, thank you for asking. It's the first time I've ever heard a parent actually seek out homeschooled students to ask them what their lives and educations were like. You may glean some very valuable information by asking that question.