Potty Training Regression - Owings Mills,MD

Updated on January 03, 2011
A.L. asks from Owings Mills, MD
4 answers

My daughter potty trained in May 2010 and has not has an accident since July 2010. It is now early January 2011 and a few weeks ago she suddenly decided she didn't want to go in the potty anymore. There was nothing drastic or traumatic that happened (no potty troubles, no constipation, no big life changes, etc.). We have asked her why she doesn't want to go and she tells us that "it isn't fun", "I don't want to" or "I don't want to stop playing to go." We are very frustrated and don't know what to do.

I've decided to "re-train" her by taking her to the potty every 1-2 hours, giving stickers for when she goes, etc. We're making her help clean up for accidents, etc. I've asked her pediatrician and he was of no help, didn't have any advice other than to call him in 2 weeks if we haven't made any progress.

We're very frustrated. I know not to punish for accidents, but we are really at the end of our rope here. I don't understand why she was potty trained for 7 months and now won't go in the potty anymore. I refuse to put her back in diapers or pull-ups. She will be 4 in February, and since she was trained I know she knows what to do and when.

Anyone have any suggestions? How long do these regressions usually last? Thanks for any help.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.W.

answers from Portland on

Hi A.,

My first question would have been to ask if your family had experienced any changes in the last few months... new caregivers, etc. But then another attraction popped into my head-- did this regression start around Christmas?

I'll tell you what I personally would do, and you can use whatever works for you. In my experience of working with kids over the last 19 years, I've learned that toileting *has to be the child's work*, and not ours. This means that other than providing support, we let the child work out some of the kinks in their own time, when they are ready.

I like the idea of taking her to the bathroom every 1-2 hours like clockwork. You are right on in not asking her IF she needs to go, but instead telling her to go use bathroom. That said, I personally would back off on the stickers and rewards. She was going just fine for a while before, right? I think stickers give it all way too much importance, and in and of themselves, can become too important. The 'reward' for using the toilet before and accident happens is staying dry.

Having her help clean up any pee is fine, just don't ask her to clean up any soiled items. This can be more fuss and actually traumatic for some kids. Do have her do what she can to help if there's more mess than she should be touching: she can still hold doors open for you or hold the paper towels, etc. Keeping her present for cleanup is a good idea.

My suggestion would be to keep getting her to the toilet, make sure not to go backward into pull-ups; if she asks for a diaper (which sometimes happens during regression) make sure it is a DIAPER, because there's often confusion around Pull-Ups 'not' being a diaper. If you have a cloth diaper to put her in, so she can still feel wet, this is optimal.

These regressions are hard to pinpoint in regard to duration. There are no two kids who are alike in anything. I have found that the more I made the regression the child's challenge to overcome, and the less emotionally involved the adults were, the more quickly the child could resolve it. When we begin stretching ourselves to accomodate 'fixing' their problem with our "adult tools" (rewards, punishments, discussions, etc.), the kids to tend to become more interested in interacting with our methods instead of their urge to go.

A nice, simple reminder might be "Do you know, it takes longer to change wet pants than it does to take a break and use the potty?"

Also, if you have multiple children present, sometimes kids are loathe to break off playing because they don't want another child to take their toys or take over what they were playing/building. At my preschool, we either set the desired toy on a shelf to 'save' for them until they've gone potty and washed their hands, or we use a light scarf/piece of fabric to cover their work area. The children know this is a signal for 'hands off, someone's working here' and they leave it alone. Kids at school are often reluctant to leave off playing too, so I send them to the bathroom when I need to, and offer the support of saving their toy/work, so we haven't had resistance to using the potty. And I do have the children change their wet clothes by themselves in the bathroom (I'll hold open the plastic bag to put their wet clothes in, because this is the trickiest part), so *they* are inconvenienced but I, more or less, am not.

As I said, this is their challenge to overcome. Good luck and I wish you plenty of patience (and emotional disengagement, because yes, it IS frustrating some days!) .

H.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.L.

answers from Washington DC on

"I know not to punish for accidents...."
EXCEPT that these are not 'accidents.' An accident is when your child is still trying to figure it out and has the occasional slip-up. You said yourself that she was already potty trained but is now refusing because it's inconvenient for her. If it were MY child, and I knew that it had nothing to do with a learning curve or constipation, she'd get a swat on the butt for each time she refused to go. She is aware how to go to the potty and is now willingly refusing. That's not a lack of ability or 'accident,' that's rebellion.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.W.

answers from Washington DC on

Could it be that she had a hard stool that hurt and caused her to not want to go anymore? At this age, who knows. My son didn't want to go for a while due to an overflowing toilet that scared him. Then he developed a fear of flushing sounds. I got out the m&ms and retrained him with them. Remain firm that she has to go, give her lots of fiber, and break out the treats and praise. Make her clean up accidents and don't give in on the no diapers or pull ups.

S.R.

answers from Kansas City on

We recently went through the same thing with our son, he will be 3 next week. About 6 weeks ago he started having accidents, just pee, he always would still poop in the potty. He has been potty trained since he was 2. It only lasted for 2-3 weeks. He had no reason for not stopping to go potty other than I didn't want to, I think he was just trying to be stubborn and have some control. I re-trained him again. I would suggest taking her more than every 1-2 hours, every 30-45 mintues is what I did with him when we re-trained.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions