S.S.
Hi C.,
I know it's frustrating. My son showed signs of being interested at 2 and a half. Now he's approaching 4 and he was still not potty trained. We've tried Elmo potty videos, potty games, reading, singing, got a special potty, no diaper in clothes, underwear, pull ups, naked and outside...Nothing worked. What's worse, it got to the point that he didn't want to sit. He cried because he didn't want to sit. So I was feeling frustrated and like the worst mom in the world.
So here's what is working now:
On the advice of another mom, we tried "potty for prizes." My son is car-crazy. My husband picked up a bunch of hot wheels and we lined up 4 or 5 (still packaged) on the back of the toilet. He's not allowed to touch them while he's trying. If he goes, he gets to pick one out and we make a big deal about it. If he doesn't go, we just say, "that's ok, next time you go potty, you can pick out a prize."
He does have tantrums, and we just explain that the rules are that he can try to go now or try later.
In 5 days with this method, now he's telling me he has to go, a new development! This morning he was so excited that he did go that he forgot all about the "prize".
I know every kid is different, but this is what's working for us...
Good luck!
S.