Dear M., Sounds like you have a real good little man, to me. He has morals and the letter writing to is a way of expressing himself. Perhaps he is a writer, there are different ways of communicating ; none of them are wrong,just different!. I was much like him as a child. My teachers would always tell me to speak up, and were always trying to pull me out of my shell.
My parents divorced in my later/teen years..try not to talk about His Dad Not being around...Honey, he already knows..it only reminds him and makes him feel unwanted and that he doesn't fit in at home.This may be some of the wanting to be perfect and being mad at himself when he messes up. I recall thinking "if I had been a better daughter"..My parents would have Not divorced. Now I know that isn't true..but then I was just a child tring to sort it all out.
I have 5 daughters..all of which have different personallitys..NONE the Same!!!I WAS USED TO MY FIRST BORN..very out going and THE LIFE OF THE PARTY AS WELL, NEVER MEETING A STRANGER TYPE!!! (This type is me as an adult).Well, my second one was just like your little man.Just different than the first;what I had become used to. (This second child was just like myself as a child). I had forgotten I was like this until she came into my life.
These are some things that helped me. Take your little man on a Mommy Date..just you and Him.Go out to eat or grogery shopping....the idea is for you 2 to be all alone. No interupptions! The library, go for a slow walk in the park, anywhere where you both enjoy. Icecream was always a favorite of my kids. Do not tell anyone what you talked about or where you went. This is supposed to be a DATE! I realize you have several children...call in the re-inforcements! Do you have anyone who can sit with the others while you have your date? 30 min. or an hour.Church family/friend(s).
Teach him his manners while he is out with you. Teach him to hold the door for you, as well as other manners he will need as he grows up (Dating). Remember this will become a special time for the two of you. You will also need to begin doing this with each of your children as they grow. Mine are all grown now with families of their own...they still will ask "When are we going on our Mommy Date?"
And they still ask "Daddy, When are we going on a date?"
Daddy Dates are important too!!! Since your husband is his daddy(raising Him) have him take him with him each time he goes; to the local hardware stores, parts stores, co-op, Lowes/Home Depot/Rural King. Man Stores! My hubby is like a kid in a candy store when he comes out of one of these stores, they do wonders for our men...I am sure it will give your little man a big boost as well.
Mommy Dates and Daddy dates thats what I would recommend!
As far as him lying....if they are flat out lies you will have to deal with this behavior. However I gave mine the right to say things like"I don't want to answer/tell you right now" At first I didn't like it...but as they grew I realized it gave them time to re-think their answers, many times Choosing NOT to lie. When you suspect he is/about to lie ask him to stop and think for a minute,because you want to give him the chance to tell the truth;as well as his side of the story.I also gave mine the right to come and talk it out.... Let me tell you one.....My oldest came in with a huge KNOT on her forehead...Screaming "Sissy hit me with a rock!!" Before I realized it..I had the younger by the arm and had drawn back to swat her. She begins telling me Her sister had been throwing rocks at her first, hitting her many times,then she dared her"You couldn't Hit The Broad side of a Barn!" well...I just stopped in mid swing. I told them "You" shouldn't have been throwing rocks at your younger sister and "You" should never let your older sister make you so MAD you try to HURT her!The younger was made to take the older into the bathroom, clean her up and put a bandaid on her forehead.This never happened again. They knew the next punishment would be they had to hold hands all day long!!HA!
My moral...make sure your son has not been put into an awkward situation....and the only thing he knows to do is Lie. He may need a little more time to tell you "WHAT" has happened. Take him away from everyone else..he could tell you more when he is not put in that situation. I Know my second child would open up more when we were one on one.
Keep trying and enjoy this Good little Man!!!! God's Blessings to You and Yours. LaDonna