Reclaiming Control over My 2 Year Old. Help???

Updated on June 03, 2013
A.Y. asks from Fresno, CA
6 answers

My two year old (will be 3 in August) is causing me to lose my mind. She has been the baby of the family up until now. I am a week or so off from having my third and final child. We had some decent size life changes in march and since then it seems like someone took my baby and replaced her with someone Ido t even know. My usually easy going kid is a monster. She was always well mannered and well behaved and since we were going through stuff I figured some of the behavioral issues were due to that. Now I'm left with a mess on my hands. The child who has never (even in her newborn stage) given me trouble at bedtime, including sleeping in her own bed and going to sleep on her own, now screams and plays for hours. Even if I am laying right next to her. She's also now waking at 430 or so in the morning. She doesn't listen and has no fear of consequence. She will clearly hear and understand that I am telling her no, yet look at me smile and continue doing whatever she wants. I've tried spankings on the bottom, time outs, taking TV and toys away. I don't know how else to turn my life back right side up. Any suggestions?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B..

answers from Dallas on

I think you have had a lot of life changes in this little one's lifetime. With more to come.

She is not a monster, she is almost a preschooler. She has claimed a personality and a temperament. You need a consistent parenting style.
Try Love and Logic. Read a book in the few mins you have left to do it.
You can find a lot at your local library. You can't keep changing because she will never figure out the rules or what the consequences might be.

Where is the father in all this? You need help.

4 moms found this helpful

L.C.

answers from Washington DC on

You need to be 100% consistent and follow through. Time out does work when done firmly and consistently. If they get up, they go back and the timer starts over. If they yell, the timer starts over. If they make noise, the timer starts over. It will get worse before it gets better.
My oldest spent a year of his life (practically) in time out, but he learned not to cross me and he turned out pretty well! :)
If the act up at a store, you leave. You leave everything behind and you walk out. If they act up at a play date or a party, you leave immediately. My son figured out that if he wanted to stay, he would need to behave. I always told him the consequences before we went in. "You need to behave. If you hit, we will leave. If you can't share nicely, we will leave. When it is time to pick up, you need to do it or you can't come back next time." I made him tell me - what happens if you hit? We go home. Yes, my boy. What happens if you are naughty? We go home. Yes, don't forget.
I hauled his sorry rear end out of exactly one birthday party for touching the cake when I told him no. I never had much trouble with him after that. :)
YMMV
LBC

4 moms found this helpful

A.J.

answers from Williamsport on

Ladybug C nailed it, but my consequence of choice was spanking because it was so effective (took once for any new infraction and warning usually sufficed since there was no need to push it to that point). It was super quick with all three of my very different kids. But like she says, it ONLY works if it's absolutely consistent and delivered EVERY time after one calm warning, not 30 warnings. I never left or did time outs, but whatever you choose, don't ever back down or take too long to react. If you're giving her consistent consequences right away EVERY TIME, how is she managing to scream and play for hours at night? Or carry anything on after the consequence? How is she managing to smile and ignore you if she's getting a consequence EVERY TIME she does that?

I'm only illustrating that because often we feel kids are invincible and impervious to all tactics, when really, we're just not being absolutely consistent. She's too young to care about taking things away but not at all too young for discipline. Actually 2 years old is sort of the cut-off for when it's easy and becomes more difficult to discipline as kids are more set in their ways. If you use spanking, be calm, immediate and consistent or DON'T use it AT ALL because it won't be any more effective than anything else, so why bring physicality into the picture? Pick your firmest and most effective tactic (surely SOMETHING had phased her in the past) and use it EVERY TIME, right away, after one warning. Soon the warning will suffice if what you have chosen is effective, and the right habits get reinforced after that through positivity and getting used to right behavior.

It's hard when you are large and pregnant, but will save you so much headache later. I've done it three times and my youngest was my toughest, but she's awesome now at three. Her brother was pretty tough and I was doing his most consistent discipline when I was pregnant too. You can do it! Keep calm, happy and loving, and act firmly and swiftly when she pulls this stuff so there is no gray area between allowed and not allowed.

When she gets out of bed, get down eye level and tell her ONCE, "Sweetie, you need to stay in bed and not cry. The next time you get out, ____Will happen." Then FOLLOW THROUGH. For the screaming, go in ONCE, "Sweetie, you have to stop screaming now. I will come back in ten seconds and if you are still screaming _______Will happen." FOLLOW THROUGH every time. If you are consistent this will be back on track in no more than three days. Be sure there is nothing medically wrong of course and be sure days are healthy and fun with enough exercise and no sugar in afternoon or evening including fruit!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.M.

answers from San Francisco on

When my middle child was 2-1/2 years old she had complete control of our family - almost exactly the same behavior you describe, both with bedtime and with consequences. One day it got so bad I ordered 7 books from Amazon on parenting, hoping to find a solution.

The book that had the solution for the behavior issue was "Parenting with Love and Logic". Previously, my daughter knew that she could get away with anything if she yelled loud and long enough, and that it was a great game when she kept getting up out of time out. The book suggested that you always give the child a choice, with both choices ending up at the desired behavior. So, I might have said, "You can either stay in time out with a swat, or you can stay in time out without a swat." I know - spanking. You can certainly use other consequences (such as taking away a toy or privilege), but the "swat" is what worked best with my daughter most of the time (I did use privileges and toy-removal from time to time as well though). I only had to give her a swat one time (lightly) and never had to do it again!

As for bedtime, I got my daughter back to going to sleep by tucking her in (after a good bedtime ritual) and telling her I'd be back in two minutes to check on her, and that she needed to remain quiet until I came back. This worked for us, as she slowly realized that I was nearby so she needn't fear, and she also needed to stay quiet. Then, I slowly extended the time between visits. Pretty soon she was going to bed with ease! It took awhile, and it was exhausting make such frequent visits at first, but it did work.

Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.G.

answers from Chicago on

It's perfectly normal developmentally. At their half bday, leading up to their bday, they regress and throw lots of crazy stuff at you. 2.5 was the worst age with my oldest, i t wasn't so bad with my second.

in any case, I would recommend the series of books by Dr Ames: http://www.amazon.com/Your-Two-Year-Old-Louise-Bates-Ames...

2.5 is too young to get consequences. They need gentle teaching moments, and lots of ignoring! She isn't listening because she is trying to have some independence from mommy. THIS IS A GOOD THING. Ignore the smiles, use distraction, and offer up choices, not orders.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.G.

answers from San Francisco on

Aw, I'm sorry. My 3rd child is 8 months old and our house was absolute hell before the baby was born, with the other 2 crying and pushing limits. You have a lot of good advice here, I just wanted to mention how much the kids sense the change and the tension in the house. Personally, I had some bad genetic test results so I was a wreck, and I don't think I fully appreciated how my mood affected the kids. This may sound counter-intuitive and hokey, but something that really helped me, was someone told me to tell them, 'I love you' at least 5 times a day. It helped keep things positive in the house. Also, when she ignores you saying no, ask her to repeat what you just said. Remind her that the screams hurt your ears, and its simply not allowed. She can scream into a pillow if she has to. React to her behavior as little as possible. Good luck! And congrats! Everything will change once she has a new sibling!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions