M.C.
Hi,
I went throught the same thing. What I discovered was that most schools require 5 day a week program with the option of pick up at noon or later. JCC and Shaarai Zedek both have very flexible programs, 2 day/ 3 day, 3hr+. I wanted to start with a 2 day a week program, I choose Shaarai Zedek for Julia my 2yr old(now 3), and very please with her experience and relationships with teachers.
I have heard about the ranch program and thought it sounded great. Parent I met in park was very happy with it.
Mothers rave about "Small Blessings", Methodist S. Tampa.
Montessori in Hyde Park requires a commitment to 6th grade with few thousand deposit. Mothers there love it. There are other Montessori or Montessory like programs which I here are very good.
Christ the King gets rave reviews.
Those are the ones I am remembering. I have not heard of any one which you would want to avaid.
Hope this helps
~M.