Hi S.,
What a tricky spot you are in. My heart goes out to you. I have a 4 year old with similar tendencies--at least he did. Until I read a lovely book called "Indigo Children". I wouldn't say I have an indigo child and certainly wouldn't say I could diagnose one, however, the results I got for my own son was dramatic enough to convince me of some truth to the idea. My little boy has always known exactly what he wants. When he was 1 1/2 to 3 years old he would often hit children for no reason except to find the most submissive child in the room. He seemed to have his agenda set and his expectations exact and if we didn't meet them--watchout, headbanging, hitting, almost hystaria. We had the best success with him when he was well rested, but even still he had rough days.
Then I learned something from him. My little boy needed to be trusted. I needed to listen to him and not push him to do things I wanted him to do for my benefit. Now don't get me wrong. We still have bounderies but I approached it much differently. This is what I learned.
1. They sense your subtleset motive!
Be honest. Admit your motives. They don't really care what they are as long as you are honest. For example if I'm feeling lazy one day, instead of trying to manipulate my children into watching a show so I can sleep, (which they don't really do for somereason when I need them too) I say, "kids, I'm really feeling lazy today, do you mind watching a movie for a little while while I sit here on the couch and do nothing?"--Magic, no problems, in fact on the other hand they treat me like gold, come and bring me pillows etc. . .
2. Say yes more. Our children want to be trusted and let their ideas be free--Not met all the time with this all powerful authority. Say yes more!
3. If you need to say no, say no and follow up with a frank and honest answer. Our children don't need authoritarian parents--they'll probably not respond.
4. Keep your promises. Or don't make one.
Now let me tell you the results of this. We decided to keep our son home from formal preschool this year, but rather start a joyschool with other moms in the neighborhoo--once a week we'd rotate houses. In addition to that, we signed him up for gymnastics once a week and a music class at Eastman once a week. For a barely 4 year old this was a full schedule. And he became the clingiest child I could've ever seen. He hated it. It got so bad that he would tell me during the day " I just don't want to be left alone all day" (keep in mind I AM home all day) All the while crying. Even if we would sit with him during his activities he rarely participated and often clung to our arms and legs not letting us leave him behind. It was so sad. And frustrating too. Finally, I remembered what I had learned. I was #1 honest with him. I explained very frankly that we enrolled him in these activities for no profit of our own. That they were just for him to enjoy and if he didn't want to participate he didn't have to.
We gave him several opportunities to back out of gymnastics first. Each day for a week I'd ask how he felt and restated why he was in the class. He decided to not go again. And actually came up with his own alternative to "have gymnastics at home and tumble on the floor." So we took him out without any questions.
The results? Beautiful! If he needed me to stay at the other activities, I'd say yes and not worry anymore because the activity was for him to enjoy and not to dread. And believe it or not 8-9 out of 10 times, about 15 min into the activity he'd say I could go. No more sneaking out, no more bribing or manipulating. I would often reinforce to him, and me too, that the activity is for him and we didn't care if he was great at what he did or why he went, we just wanted him to enjoy the class and thought he'd really benefit by it. In short, he loves and trusts his music class. He loves and trusts his preschool teachers and he goes happily and on the days he doesn't feel like going alone, we don't make a big deal about it but talk to him honestly stay for a while and when he's ready he'll let us go. Besides, I know there will come a time in our children's lives when they won't want us around at all. And that time is coming sooner than we realize. Best of luck and keep enjoying your little boy. Don't worry. Just get him some good rest and ENJOY him there's no rush!
V.