Wow, you definitely have your hands full. Twins are so challenging. What I'm reading is that, in order to preserve THEIR sleep, you aren't getting any. And neither are they because they are both waking up a few times anyway. So, first of all, I think your doctor will confirm that, at this age, they do not need to eat during the night - they will make up for it with more food during the day. I think you need to try one method - we used cry it out, but you can do something else if you want. Just embrace the method and do it consistently no matter what. If Luke wakes Olivia, it doesn't really matter, because Olivia is slated to wake up in another hour and then wake Luke, right? Just rub each baby's back, say "Night night, time for sleep, see you in the morning" or whatever phrases you prefer - but say the same thing. Establishing a pattern is essential. Go in less and less often - stretching it out more each time. Even if they holler for 30 minutes, it's really okay - they aren't in trouble and they must learn to self-soothe. It's agonizing, I know, but after 3-4 days of no sleep (which you aren't getting now anyway), it will be done. You will have 2 well-rested babies who get plenty of nutrition during the day, and you will be sane at the end of it. Good luck!