K.T.
I agree that you should definitely get at least one more opinion before you make any big decisions! My daughter, who is now not quite 2 years old, broke her front tooth last July and we went to Children's Hospital Dental Clinic for a walk-in appointment the next morning. We loved the dentist that we saw that day and when we found out he had an office in Powell we started seeing him there. His name is Dr. Jeff Milton at Olentangy Pediatric Dentistry.
Good luck!