Dear Shandon,
My precious little cherub daughter went through a phase of being ummm, let's call it creative with her poop. Both in her crib and in the bathtub. I immediately freaked about the mess and having it on my precious baby so I went to work straight away getting her cleaned up and cleaning everything else. I told her NO!, YUCK!, DIRTY! Mommy is NOT happy! I tried everything. Then one day when she did it, I was so fed up, I got on the phone and called my mom. My daughter could see that I was on the phone basically ignoring the situation. She started fussing and I said, "You must like things this way, so you can just stay in there with your poop." After a few minutes, she was crying and having a fit and I just let her. Then she was yelling, "Momma! YUCKY!" My mom was hearing the whole thing and I was talking about the weather and pretending to ignore my daughter. I left her in there with her mess for about 10 minutes instead of rushing to clean it all up, and she never did it again. In fact, she didn't even want poop in her diaper anymore. She wanted to flush it bye-bye in the toilet.
It may sound harsh, but I was at my wit's end with it. I knew I had another big mess to clean so I took a deep breath and called my mom before starting the whole sanitizing ritual. 10 minutes is a long time...maybe she thought I would never clean it that time, I don't know. but it worked. At least for her.
My son never did that one single time. From the time he was brand new, he couldn't stand being wet or dirty so he was very easy to potty train.
All kids are different. I hope you'll find what works!