My Daughter's Bff's Mom Seemingly Wants to Separate Girls and Has Become Unkind
Updated on
October 05, 2010
J.G.
asks from
Chicago, IL
8
answers
My 8 year old daughter has been best friends with another little girl for 3 years. In that time our families have become friends. The other mom and I necessarily work closely together on many school based projects. At the beginning of their friendship this other mother admittedly handpicked my daughter as a close friend for hers - for reasons of respect and academics. The friendship has been - over the course of time - fairly balanced.
Over this past summer my daughter's friend was unusually unavailable. Over the three years, I have witnessed this mom manipulate who her children play with in controlling not necessarily constructive ways. I can't really figure out what turned the tide.
At the beginning of this school year the other mom and I discussed the importance of the girls having many friends, not merely a best friend. This year I believe that both girls have reached out in more depth to the girls they had always been friends with. However the best friend reached out to another little girl who has had a 3 year history of bullying my daughter - to the point that the school got involved -even prior to my knowledge. This friendship between my daughter's alleged best friend and a girl who had continually bullied her - but less so just this year - was difficult for my daughter. After very much discussion, she learned to compartmentalize it and was able to move through a day without allowing it all to affect her overall happiness. I felt it inappropriate to ask the other mom to take measures to keep a distance between her daughter and this other girl. In hindsight, I wish I would have been direct and asked exactly that - only knowing that she would have - without question - asked as much of me.
Over the past month, this mom has now become unduly critical of my daughter. At first report, my reaction was to completely favor the adult's point of view. It's how I was raised and my feeling is that if I'm - for lack of a better word - "hard"- on my children, the world will be less so. I do however absolutely allow my children to recant their story prior to any discipline - or even prior to giving any impression of my position. So, I took the adult's report with more weight than my own knowledge of my daughter - and was (inside) pretty upset with my daughter. However after open-endedly questioning my daughter on 2 separate occasions it was very clear that her behavior was entirely fine.
My daughter is a total and complete authority figure "pleaser". She has never been involved in any unkind, unfair or bully like behavior at school. She has received school recognition for her respectful behaviors. She sees her best friend's mom as an authority figure and can't even begin to imagine how she (the mom) could be so unduly critical to her and unfair. My (8 year old) daughter actually approached the other mom and apologized for what seemed like a misunderstanding, she respectfully explained her side and the other mom stood her ground and couldn't even concede that the two situations might have been a misunderstanding. -Not even an agreement to disagree respectfully or any gracious show of warmth from the other mom - which then left my daughter feeling that she was wrong.
Even worse, the other girl (the best friend) has now also started to pick on my daughter. This same girl was the insistently self proclaimed best friend of my daughter for the past several years.
If our families hadn't become friends and my daughter wasn't so truly interested in staying friends with the other girl, we'd cut ties. My daughter sees the other girl as very popular and is honored to be her best friend (she doesn't fancy herself popular at all). My daughter still wants to be friends even though the other little girl has become unkind at times. I'm working on that - a matter of "self" respect.
My daughter has tried to discuss her feelings with the other little girl (who is just typically more care free and less a pensive thinker and talker) and the other little girl has dismissed the issue. Most currently I have suggested that my daughter nicely and quickly address the unkind remarks as they occur... ie: to an unkind remark of - "why would you make that stupid design on your paper?" ....our reply - "because it was my interpretation of our teacher's instruction and I like it". or with a certain tone, "you think you're the only one who... (fill in the blank)"... our reply - "why would you ask me that question?" or simply "please don't talk to me like that".
I do not wish to meddle to mend, manipulate or fabricate friendships for my children. I am of the mind that most things should be handled amongst the kids but this one breaks my heart and is creating much anxiety for both me and my daughter.
Our families are a bit intertwined and the other mother is clearly not open for discussion.
Another sticky detail, we extended an invitation to their family many months ago to vacation together - unfortunately those plans stand.
Thank you so very much for your thoughtful feedback and support!
I am creating distance at every opportunity. I am also encouraging my daughter to continue to reach out to her other friends and strengthen those relationships. The actions of this other family continue to upset me but I am making deliberate choices to not dwell on the 'why' and rather to focus on moving forward in a more constructive manner.
There are still moments of sadness for my daughter when her 'best friend' disappoints her with an unkind comment or a lack of commitment to their friendship. With every passing day however I see her getting stronger and creating distance and other relationships/ support in her own way. Thus is her way. She always takes things in, thinks, thinks some more then thinks a little while longer and while continuing to think moves forward in ways that impress and touch her mom and dad's hearts.
It is so difficult to witness the pain our children endure as they grow and learn. In the end, at least she's learning and growing in our proverbial arms. Perhaps through it all she/ they will face the world better prepared once they leave the literal closeness of our arms. I pray.
The vacation plans remain. Hopefully before that time we will be less emotionally vested in those relationships and will therefore be able to share the time and enjoy the events on a more 'superficial' level. - Not as best friends or close family friends 'betrayed' but instead more as people who know each other and are sharing time. I hope that we will have less expectation of a depth of friendship - so that we won't allow the disappointments of the past (or even present) to ruin our own vacation time.
Thanks again to all of you who thoughtfully weighed in to help this mom and her daughter!
More Answers
K.L.
answers from
Terre Haute
on
From my own personal experience growing up, you're never going to get anywhere with these people by playing nice. When I was in elementary school I was good friends with a girl down the road who was in the same grade as me. I came from an average middle class family and her family owned a business and her dad was a lawyer, very wealthy. We got a long great but I was not good enough for her mom. Her mom made it impossible to be friends with her. I watched her mom over the years place her daughter in situations and around certain kids to make her daughter look good. I really think that your daughter was good enough to be her daughters friend until your daughter became a threat in some way. Who knows what changed to make it like this, it could have just been some small comment another parent or maybe a family member made to her about your daughter that just rubbed her the wrong way. Its nothing you guys did, its just them. They are the a-typical mother/daughter of this day and age they are fine until they feel threatened by you. This bully offers an opportunity to this mom. The bully makes her daughter look like a saint and it keeps the bully from picking on her daughter. I think you have nobly tried to do the right thing in this situation but I think it is time to stop. You need to stand up to this this lady and you need to encourage your daughter to stand up for herself. There is a time and place for everything and I don't agree with going off and cussing people out but there is a diplomatic way to do so. Stop trying to salvage the relationship and just move on. Take it from me my mom always pushed me to be the good girl, turn the other cheek, respect everyone etc. I think she was too extreme because I had a lot of anxiety problems growing up from what I put up with, with classmates. Anxiety is awful!! Don't let your daughter grow up with problems. Just because you stand up for yourself it doesn't make you a bad person, even if you have to let them have it a little bit! I know I don't know the people and the exact circumstances but from what you wrote I think you've done all you can, you need to just let it go and move forward and stop trying to be their friend still. Good luck and I will say a prayer for you and your daughter (and for the meanies too) :)
6 moms found this helpful
Report This
K.U.
answers from
Detroit
on
I'm sorry, forgive me for being blunt, but I just don't understand why you would want to continue to be friends with these people. If this mother is supposed to be your friend, why would she be anything but kind and gracious to your daughter? And if you are supposed to all be friends, why can't you have a discussion with her and try to get these things out in the open?
Your daughter needs you to back her up and be her "soft place to land" - she will find out soon enough how hard the real world can be, sounds like she is finding that out already, she needs to know you will always be there to support her, even when you know she was wrong or you think she should have done something differently. Your daughter wants so badly to be friends with this one other girl, and it seems like you want to continue the friendship with her mother as well, and yet at the same time, you are trying to teach your daughter how to have enough self-respect to stand up for herself while you continue to allow this other mother to treat you and your daughter poorly. What are you hoping to gain by being friends with them? And why can't you just withdraw the invitation for the vacation together? If this is how they are going to treat you, why would you want to keep hanging around them? The other girl's mom has already shown how manipulative she can be, why should you and your daughter be seeking her approval?
I have many, many good friends that I know are true friends - they don't play games and they don't go behind my back. If this is how someone feels is okay to treat you, they are not a real friend. I think it is time to let these "friends" go.
4 moms found this helpful
Report This
L.B.
answers from
New York
on
I teach my kids that friends are people that they feel good about being around, people who treat them well and who are there for them and who they would be there for in return. There are real friends and people who you know and may talk to and play with sometimes but they are not the people that will be there for you. My 9 year old daughter understands this - as she had a friend who treated her badly, but she desparately wanted to be friends with this girl anyway. I did not want my daughter to gravel for someones friendship, I taught her to distance herself and make other friends, I taught her that it wasn't her, it was the other girl who wasn't the good friend. My daughter now has other good friends who treat her well and the little girl in question sometimes sits with my daughter on the bus and we see her sometimes but it is no big deal if we do or don't. In fact, now that my daughter does not "chase" the friendship the girl seems to want to play with her more, but my daughter is too busy playing with friends that treat her well!
Like you, I was friends with the girls mother, we are neighbors, Our families went camping together, etc...I tried talking to the other mother, it didn't work. I just distanced ourselves because I did not want to beg for a friendship and certainly did not want my daughter to beg for someones friendship or to appear needy. Guess what that other mother calls me once in awhile, we walk together sometimes, sometimes work on a school project together, but that is it!
My point you can distance yourself without being mean, just make boundaries and make yourself unavailable. Stay true to yourself and teach your daughter to feel good about herself and that she deserves friends that treat her well and to play with kids that make her feel good about herself!
2 moms found this helpful
Report This
B.C.
answers from
Norfolk
on
This other mother sounds like a social climber with an agenda known only to herself. What ever her criteria for friends for her daughter are, the winds could change and she might want to be friendly again.
The question is, would/should you take her back? I wouldn't. Be cordial but distant. Minimize contact, and once this vacation is over, don't make vacation plans to be together again.
In the mean time, you and your daughter should sign up for some taekwondo. It's a great way to meet people, and I've seen several children/parents who take classes together. It builds self confidence and you learn to stand up for yourself.
It would do a world of good for both of you.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
A.D.
answers from
Minneapolis
on
I feel for you and your daughter. I would stop calling them, you do not need to put more effort into people who are unkind. Be cordial, I wouldn't even have a big discussion, but I would definitely create a little healthy distance between your family and theirs. Point your daughter in the direction of a few activities away from this girl, and ecourage her to invite a few nicer girls for playdates. Tell your daughter that sometimes people grow apart. If spending time with this girl is continually more misery than fun, she has the power to choose to surround herself with other people. Honestly, if you witnessed the Mom be unkind to your daughter, I would find a way to get out of vacationing together.
1 mom found this helpful
Report This
M.M.
answers from
Washington DC
on
I agree with Kristel. Somehow your daughter or you threatened this woman. It could be that she knws how respectful your daughter is and sees her getting awards and hers is not. It could be that someone said something very nice about you or your daughter and she feels some credit is due her way. Whatever she is playing games with both of you.
Tell your daughter there are other fish in the sea, so to speak, and encourage other friendships. Start inviting other little girls over. Do not invite the one who is being manipulated to be mean to your child.
Entoll her into Girl Scouts or a Tae Kwon Do class or something she can do that will give her confidence. Maybe swimming lessons at the Y.
This breaks my heart for your daughter, but some people are just plastic and it's a hard lesson to learn.
Report This
C.S.
answers from
Las Vegas
on
You are mom and you can guide her, there is nothing wrong with that. My adult daughter comes home all the time with hurt feelings from work and tells me someone may have said something out of line to her. I sometimes give her feedback from both sides, as I am able to listen and take a different view as I take a step back. Of course, I never call her friends and persuade them here nor there, it is all done one sided.
As for the mom who would accept her apology, I would let your daughter know, there will be people like that and encourage her to not let that hurt her feelings. I believe that is a problem within that person and your daughter did the right thing.
Report This
C.F.
answers from
Chicago
on
Maybe while on vacation together the opportunity will present itself that you can all have a discussion. What do the fathers think or are they staying out of this. If you all get to talk then prayerfully that will clear the air. you will know whether to hold on or cut your ties. Children need to learn that som people can be toxic in their life and they need to let go so that they don't get infected with the toxic stuff. Sit and talk with your daughter and tell her that she will have many people that will come into her life, not all are friends. If this girl was really her best friend she could never have become friends with someone that hurt her best friend. Some people are only ment to be in our life for a season and maybe that season has come to an end. This is a hard lesson for an 8 year old but she needs to learn this because she needs to figure out who is a friend and who is and aquantance, especially before HS.