J.R.
Hi A.,
I have to admit... I was very drawn to giving birth in the water. I am a water sign, and it's very comforting to me. If i feel sick in any way, I always take a bath. water is my cure all and always makes me feel better :)
That being said, I typically labored at home for as long as possible and taking a bath was part of my 'routine' (my water never broke spontaneously so this wasn't an issue). But really once I got to the hospital, most of my 'birth plan' went out the window. I planned for music to be playing while I gave birth and midway thru pushing I became darn near violent about the "Friggin noise" - though I believe I used another choice expletive :) the mere thought of getting up out of bed and getting into a tub was lost... then I begged for the epidural because after laboring for 72 hours, frankly, I was exhausted.
So while I do think in some situations, with the voice of a midwife or doula to push your desires on the hospital staff and then back on you so that YOU adhere to your plan, it can be rewarding in many ways. But I think since hypnobirthing is still considered somewhat an alternative to the 'norm' you really need a team of people to be your voice and ensure your plan is played out the way you want by everybody involved, barring complications.
So.... that's my thoughts :)