Hi D.,
Both my girls have ear tubes. My older is 3 and got her first set at 13 months and my little one is 14 months and got her first set on January 29. My older girl had her 3rd set at the end of June. I can tell you that it has been excellent. Both girls had tons of ear infections, one right after the other, so getting ear tubes was the option for us(although my older did get her tonsils/adenoids out at 17 months also and really needed that).
I won't lie - it was scary for me because of the unknown and not knowing what you don't know. I didn't go for a second opinion because our pediatrician thought it was a good idea. I also go to an ENT that comes HIGHLY recommended by tons of friends who also had the procedure done. I can tell you that the whole procedure is quick. Due to my girls age they went close to first, if not first. The procedure was set for 7:30am and we were home by 10am with a 45 minutes commute to the hospital. The procedure itself is about 3-5 minutes per ear. It's less than a 1/2 hour (might have been 15 minutes) from the time the baby was taken from us until the time we were told it all went well and we can go see her. Then it took about an hour or so to come off from the anestesia and she drank so that we were able to be released. I think the worst part of the whole thing was that last part because all kids react differently to anestesia. My older was all over the place and my little one cried more than normal because she just felt weird I guess.
Please feel free to email me if you want any more information.
Good luck - it will all be fine.
S.