Okay--before I put in this response, I want to put in a preface. This is coming from someone who did NOT grow up in a church, was never comfortable in a church, and did everything she possibly could to run AWAY from God for years.
I strongly recommend my church. It's CrossView Christian Church and the website is www.crossviewchristian.org. It's "officially" in Waynesville, but it's not as far away as it might sound. :) On 48, you head out past the Kroger and Elder-Beerman going OUT of Centerville and turn left onto Social Row--about 5 minutes up the road from there (you can't miss it--it sits at a four-way stop sign). On Wilmington Pike, you can also hit the four-way, but you'd have to mapquest that one because I don't go that way often enough to give good directions. :)
It is a non-denom that not only teaches, but works to get the whole congregation involved (without feeling like you have a gun to your head). Right now I'm helping to teach with a 4-year old "Tuesday School" class where they get to spend time with crafts, music, a kid-friendly "chapel" time, and LOTS of learning. I'm also in two bible studies and I had been in a prayer ministry until my Tuesday started to look too much like I was a full-time worker again. :)
If you're into bible studies, they have lots of options running right now. If you like reading and studying books, if you prefer to study books directly from the bible, if you would want to be involved in a MOPS (Mothers of Preschoolers) program...they're all here. For men, they have a 6:30 a.m. breakfast on Friday mornings for bible studies and they're getting ready to restart Saturday morning breakfasts as well (I believe those are just once a month). Plus, they find other projects or things to attend (my husband went with them to Promise Keepers in Cincinnati right before Labor Day).
The other thing that I really like about our church is that it's friendly. I've been in several other churches in the area where you feel like you're an outsider even if you've attended there for awhile (my family went to another church for several months and it STILL never felt like we were welcome).
Feel free to send me a message if you would like to know more or just have questions. :)