Used Goods!

Updated on October 19, 2009
P.C. asks from Hopewell Junction, NY
7 answers

Hi Moms!
I have a delema of sorts.
I have an Aunt that comes to visit 1-2 times a year.
She is actually a good friend of the family that I grew up calling my Aunt.
I and my sister absolutely love and cherish her so I do not wish to offend her, but I have a little problem.
When she comes to visit she says that she is coming because she has a bunch of gifts for my daughter (Now 21 months). Most of the time she has bestowed gorgeous quilts that she has made for my daughter and I am more than gracious in receiving them. They will be treasured heirlooms for generations to come if I have my way, BUT....
She also comes with items she has picked up at garage sales, or 2nd hand stores etc.
This last visit she brought my daughter a bag full of books that were 2nd hand and she gave her a pink Barbie cell phone. Ok, fine books are great, but I would have liked to have cleaned them a bit before she gave them to my daughter. ( I was not aware these were 2nd hand until after my daughter was using them) God knows where they came from.
And then she confessed that she found the pink cell phone under her car in the street somewhere!!!
I mean really, my daughter is not lacking for anything...in fact I think she has too much.

I am not offended with this but I just don't understand why she would give my daughter a toy she found in the street. When I see a toy in the street I say, "Oh some child is missing that", but I don't go and pick it up and give it to my child!
Cleary a different generation,,,,,she is from the depression years and has never gotten out of that mind set I guess.
We are not rolling in the dough either, but it is not to that extreme that I have to get these items from the street or who knows who's basement for my daughter to have something.
How do I handle the future visits and the future gifts without hurting my dear Aunt's feelings?
I guess I would just like the opportunity to inspect them myself and clean them before my daughter plays with them.
I am usually not at a loss for words but she is a very special person to me and I don't want to hurt her in any way.

Thanks for your help Mom's!
P.

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.P.

answers from Rochester on

I grew up with a grandma who was always bestowing these kinds of gift to me and my brother and now have an older neighbor who brings boxes of these things to my son. I suppose I would suggest taking it in stride. Let her enjoy the act of giving and if you don't want you daughter to have it take it away when your aunt leaves--we usually have a box of items to return to the thrift store after our neighbor visits. Furthermore, some of our favorite family stories are talking about the things Grandma Jean would bring for us--she once showed up with a lamb (a real live lamb), but our favorite was the "I Love Bingo" pin she lovingly wrapped and gave to my brother--he foolishly chose it as the gift he wanted to open on Christmas eve.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.R.

answers from New York on

Hi P.,

Your aunt sounds like my uncle.. Lol.. We just had the same thing happen on Saturday. My uncle came over with some toys, which personally I think that he picked up at a garage sale or just found somewhere. They were dirty and really needed a cleaning prior to my son touching them. This is how we cope with the situation whenever it has occurred.
First: We made it very clear to our friends and family that we like to clean all of his toys prior to giving them to him, even the new ones in boxes. (I know sounds a little maniacal, but we have become germaphobes).
Second: We request that all used toys be given to us in our hands and not his. When he is opening new gifts, we go with step 3.
Third: We have shown our son that toys need to be cleaned first and then we can play with them. At this point we usually have the Clorox Clean up Spray ready with paper towels and clean the toys in his presence.

For board books, we wipe down the covers and pages. If they are hand me downs, as long as you clean them, I don't see why kids can't have them.
Now if it's just that you find it disgusting to have hand me downs due to fear of not getting the items clean enough, express this to your loved ones. I think that anyone who knows you well enough and whom you have a strong relationship with should not find it insulting that you express your concerns. You could also suggest that due to the fact that you feel your daughter has enough, that if they want to visit your child, they do not need to bring a gift along.

Take care.
D.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.D.

answers from Albany on

I have this problem with my mother-in-law, and we handled it just as Deb said - unwrap/unpack, then encourage your daughter to help wash the items. I also make fun of my "germ-a-phobe" tendencies (though I'm really not a germ-o-phobe!). It took a while, but the message sunk in. I never had a "talk" with my MIL, and she doesn't seem to mind that my dd can't play with her 2nd-hand gifts right away.

One other suggestion I have: If you're trying to emphasize that your daughter doesn't need more stuff, you can soften the message by letting well-meaning gift givers know that there's a new rule in your house: one in, one out. When a new toy comes in, an old toy must go. It makes them think twice about the gifts they give - is it just junk that will get tossed soon or is it really something worthwhile?

Good luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.P.

answers from New York on

I would speak with your aunt and let her know that you and your husband are working to teach your daughter the value of spending time with treasured people rather than with "items". Tell her that you appreciate her spending time with your daughter and that 1-2 books are wonderful, but you are hoping that she will not come to expect a gift with each visit (which is true).

If she continues to bring the gifts, then I would take the bag at the door and let her know that you are going to bring them out little-by-little so that your daughter has surprises spread-out. That way you can look through, clean and get rid of things that your daughter won't use!

I think if you phrase it coming from a "value the person, not the thing" perspective you may get further. Perhaps she has a special cookie recipe that she can make with your daughter- how special to have pictures of that when your daughter is older!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.C.

answers from New York on

Next time you Aunt calls to say she's coming to visit with a bunch of gifts. Tell her great, you can't wait to see her and spend time with her...but in terms of the gifts, let her know you are overwhelemed at this point with toys...would she mind if you put what she is bringing away with out the child seeing them first until you have more time to go through and get rid of what the child already has out, that she has out grown or doesn't play with anymore to make room for the new toys she is bringing....it's a process you do while the child is sleeping and you haven't had time to do this lately and mention not to worry when you give the new toys to her you'll make sure she knows they are from her favorite aunt.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.M.

answers from New York on

Hi P.,

Try having your Aunt give these gifts at a time when your daughter will have very little time to play with them, like before bed time or dinner. That way you will have a chance to inspect and wash them first.

You could try talking to your Aunt and explaining that you would prefer that your daughter only receive one or two very special gifts rather than a large quantity.

Good luck.

C.A.

answers from New York on

Well maybe you could just put the items on the side and occupy your daughter with something else until you can look and clean the items. Like with books... maybe put them to the side and tell your aunt that you will read them to her when she goes to bed. Same for toys. Change the subject and then your daughter will play with other things. I had a simular situation. My Aunts cousins are mentally challenged and one of them gave my daughter a butterfly keychain. Now mind you they are not the cleanest people but it was the thought that counted. I just told her that I will put it in my pocket so that she doesn't lose it. I then brought it home and scrubed the heck out of it and then gave it to my 20 month old daughter to play with.
When your "aunt" leaves look it over and if you are not satisfied with the condition then just throw it away. Since your daughter has so many things and she only visits occasionally then she won't ask about the items.
Hope that this helps. Good Luck!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches