What I want to know is WHEN and WHY "judging" suddenly became pejorative.
How do we know what is right or wrong? We judge it to be so.
Now, I'm pretty laid back. As long as you aren't hurting anyone, do whatever you like. I couldn't care less. (And if you are hurting someone, it may well be justified. Justified. Justice. Judged to be the morally correct thing to do in a given situation.)
If, however, someone ASKS me to care... that's a different matter. They are ASKING me to judge their situation and give advice in accordance with either my opinion or my experience. Now... that gives me no right to their situation. My judgement is x, y, z... but I have no right to be offended if they don't take my 2 cents. For that's all it is. My viewpoint concerning the situation presented to me.
What bakes my noodle is when people are asking to be judged or for a situation to be judged, and then disagree with the judgements of others, and get offended and angry with people for doing exactly as they asked. If you're looking for people to weigh in, they're going to weigh in.
You do realize you're ASKING me to judge the situation, yes?
Judging. Judgement. Showing GOOD JUDGEMENT, or bad judgment. Judgement of character. Accurate judgement. Inaccurate judgement. Judging situations, people by their actions/words/intent... this is a foundation of CHARACTER. The clockwork of our moral compasses.
But all of a sudden (or so it seems) "judgement" has become some kind of terrible thing to avoid doing.
Say what???
I'm sorry, but how is a person supposed to know what is right or wrong, smart or regrettable, safe or dangerous; if they aren't judging themselves, others, and situations?
There's a BIG difference between judgment (that word now sounds funny in my head, I've said it too many times) and intolerance. Or arrogance.
It really vexes me when people use the wrong words. It's not a "little judgy". It may be toweringly arrogant, however. Or short sighted. Or bigoted. Or without merit or understanding (aka ignorant). Or it may be dead to rights, with due concern, or informed by experience.
Judgement is NOT A BAD WORD.
((I appear to have joined your vent. Sorry for neither brining martinis nor coffee, depending on time of day and personal inclination))
"Don't judge me."
Why not??? I have no authority of most people. My judgement means nil. Being ASKED not to judge to harshly or quickly I may take under advisement, however. That's a request to avoid speed/ rush to judgement or to temper my thoughts. I may. But "don't judge me" is an oxymoron. I can. I do. I shall. But it doesn't MEAN anything unless I actually hold power over your life. It's reeeeally easy to bestow and rescind power over your life when asking to be judged. Forcibly being judged (like in a court of law), is a different matter. But otherwise, it's just playing Kind Canute to walk around demanding not to be judged. Arrrgh. Vexing.