A Question for a Girl I Know

Updated on March 04, 2008
C.R. asks from Enumclaw, WA
5 answers

Ok, so i went to school with this girl... Not good friends with her but another one of my good friends is. She is 19.
Ok, so she has been married less than a year. She had a baby with him before they were married. Anyways, he is very very very abusive to her every way possible. Well heres the catch, she met this other guy.... After telling her husband that she didnt wanna be hurting anymore.... The thing is he is 46 almost 47. I dont know what to say... I wanna laugh but then feel bad for her at the same time. This 46 year old made the girl that was staying at his house that he had been seeing... But not really. They werent happy... He told her to leave and told her that he loved this other girl.... (the girl that i know). So everytime her husband finds out that she went and saw him he breaks down asking why would she do that... He doesnt take any blame. What should this girl do. I have seen the girl i know and the 46 year old around... And he treats her awesome.... But he has kids older than her.... I just dont know what to say.

Any help that i can tell her?

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.T.

answers from Seattle on

You may want to pass on to her that if they will cheat with you they will cheat on you... Also it wouldn't be a good idea to get to involved with this other guy at first because there is a high likelyhood that it is just a rebound relationship. She really needs to weigh the pro's and con's of the relationship He'll be almost 70 when she is 40 and her kid is 20. What she really needs to focus on is getting her education in a field that she can easily support herself and child when and if needed, that way if she stays with the older guy and he dies early she won't be left stranded. And get some serious mental health counseling so that she can make the best choices for her child and self.

1 mom found this helpful

M.B.

answers from Seattle on

C.,

This girl is 19, legally an adult, and should be able to make her own decisions. About the only thing I would tell her is to get out of the abusive relationship, and not look back, or believe anything the abuser says, EVER!!!.

As for the other man, that is a sticky situation, to say the least, but that is her decision and not really something you should bring up, even if it doesn't seem morally appropriate to you.

Hope this helps,
Kindly,
Melissa

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.P.

answers from Portland on

Encourage her to get started with counseling!!!!!

She definately needs to get out of the abusive relationship and the relationship with her new man. I suspect this new guy is a substitute for a father who takes care of you as well as a source for romance. Since he's unmarried at 47 and having a woman living with him whom he kicks out, I already know he doesn't know how to nurture a relationship.

Even if he could take care of her, I have never seen a rebound relationship last. Already she knows how this new man treats a woman when he decides to take another one. She is causing herself more pain and grief now and in the future. She needs to know why she makes decisions that cause her more pain. Isn't it painful to see her husband cry and plead? Won't she cry when the new man finds someone else?

Help her find support without the entanglements of a romantic relationship. That's what women friends are all about.

I also feel so very sorry for that baby. The baby's needs should come first for the mother. It sounds like she has so many needs herself that she can't focus on the baby. Perhaps she should allow the baby to be cared for by someone more able to provide for his emotional needs. The obvious one unmet now is a sense of security. These little babies are born with a great sensitivity to their surroundings and relationships. That is how they are able to survive. The first 5 years are crucial in a person's life. If their many needs are not met, they have the sort of problems this mother is having now.

When my mother was too depressed with postpartum depression and my father couldn't care for us full time (he worked 2 jobs) we kids lived with an aunt and uncle until they got their life back together. That isn't the ideal but it's sure better than living with parents who are overwhelmed with their own needs, fighting and crying and looking for security for themselves "in all the wrong places."

To be successful in a new relationship one must be finished with the old. That includes both a physical and an emotional divorce. Everyone needs to learn about themselves and about their decisions and actions that created the old relationship. We must learn how to develop a new relationship without repeating the old.

I wish her the best. If you don't spend time with her you cannot do anything, even offer advice. Perhaps you can share these answers with her friend so that she has insight into what is happening and hopefully make suggestions to her friend that will cause her to think again about what is happening.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.S.

answers from Portland on

Your friend needs to get out of the relationships and learn to be alone and be happy with herself. He primary job now is not finding a man that makes her happy, it is raising her baby and doing what's best for him/her. The older man is using her too, just not abusing her yet. Your friend probably did/does not have a good relationship with her father. She doesn't think she deserves any better than the man she married, and she is in a weird way using this older man and a serrogate father. She needs to love herself and believe that she is worth good things, or she will leave one abusive relationship and seek out another.

E.B.

answers from Seattle on

It sort of sounds like she is using the older guy to get out of a tough spot. As long as she is happy i wouldnt doing anything. She sort of sounds like she depends on people or rather men so as long as she has one that isnt hurting her really after a certain age i dont really think the age of the two people matter.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches